Don't get this one.
The non waterproof one works 100x better.
AWFUL. The applicator is really tough and it's impossible to get a solid line. This is by far the WORST eyeliner out there. It's not that water proof, and very hard to put on, and the line will never be nice and solid. It also wrinkles when it dries. Oh, and when you've worn it for a while, it get sticky and hold on to your lid. Soooooo bad.
This is the only eye liner i will ever use again! I use it everyday, and i only need to buy a new one probably once every 6 months. It is waterproof and very hard to get off which is what i wanted. I do not want my eyeliner running down my face. As long as you give it a second to dry before opening your eye it will be perfect, if not then some will go onto your lid. I LOVE the tip because it is not Flexible its more like a marker and my lines are flawless. The black is dark and the color stays. BEST EYELINER EVER and its 3 bucks.
DO NOT BUY THIS LIQUID LINER, PLEASE. The felt tip applicator is not flexible at all and hurts to use. It is so stiff, and cannot create a smooth, precise line at all. If the applicator was of a higher quality, I would like this product a lot more, but it just makes it impossible to use the eyeliner. I feel really bad throwing out gently used makeup, but I literally cannot use this eyeliner because of how awful the applicator is.
I use liquid eyeliner almost everyday. When I was out of town not too long ago, I ran out of my go to liner and picked this up at the local Walmart. My lids tend to be oily so I applied a primer before applying it. What I noticed right away was that the tip was really hard and the product seemed very liquidy and wet. The color was nice though so I hoped I would end up liking it. It took a long time for it to dry and I thought that after the eyeliner dried up in the bottle it would work better. By the end of the day, the liner was either smudged off or had transferred above the lid. This eye liner would have been nice if you have dry to normal lids and used a good primer but I don't think I will be getting it again.
I had high hopes for this product when I bought it, even forcing my frugal self to pay a little more than my usual eyeliner (usually $3 vs. about $6 for this) as I am trying to switch all my products to cruelty free brands. The applicator is a little stiff which is not really not a huge issue, I just ended up using the applicator from an old bottle of the brand I used to use and it worked fine. The main problem I had with this product arose after I had applied it, in the aspect that it transfers and smudges easily. Even after it had dried a small amount of oil from my eyelids caused it to transfer and leave these weird lines right around my crease when I blinked. It is very annoying and not very good for the delicate skin around my eyes to have to tug and rub at them all day in order to remove all the transferred product. I will probably look for a way to resolve the issues and continue to use until I run out (more out of frugality than anything), but I will not be repurchasing.
I had sooooo many issues with this product when I bought it. The smudging, the terrible applicator--it was horrible next to its non-water proof other! However...then I realized something...THE PROBLEM IS THE APPLICATOR. It is hard and doesn't allow for quick, easy strokes like the regular liquid eyeliner. I used the applicator from the regular eyeliner I had ran out of after washing it off and it worked like a miracle! It came on smooth, no smudging, and looked professional, and it is water proof like it claims, which is a good and bad thing. With the original applicator brush, if you messed up, which happened pretty much every time you put it on because of the horrible brush, you would be stuck with smudgy makeup the rest of the day. However, I have not messed up once using the brush from the Wet 'n' Wild Liquid Eyeliner, and it stayed on all day. Of course it is hard to wash it off at night but it is well worth the all-day coverage.
This is very black and easy to use. I think it's easy to use. Many find that it isn't but this was my first experience with liquid liner (I usually use gel or pencil liners) and I found it easy to apply. My one gripe is, as the reviewer below me also noticed, it will get on your eyelashes and dry so applying mascara is not as smooth as it normally is. It makes your lashes spidery. I will play with it a little bit. I said I would buy it again and I may, but I want to try other liners first as this was my first one and I'm sure there are better ones out there.
This eyeliner has really good staying power. I only have to apply it once a day and it doesn't smudge once it's dry. (It even is pretty resistant to makeup remover). Its main flaw is that it is not a user friendly product. If you get any of it on your eyelashes, it is there to stay and it makes your mascara clump on to it. If you hold your finger over your eyelashes you can avoid it clumping in your eyelashes and making a mess of your mascara, but it makes drawing a straight line really difficult so I have to apply it very slowly. I luckily don't have the problem of the eyeliner smudging before I'm done, but I can see how that would happen to others because I get eyeliner on my finger when I'm shielding my eyelashes and it takes a lot of rubbing makeup remover on my finger to get the eyeliner off.
So not horrible, but don't necessarily recommend and likely wouldn't buy again (their eyeliner pot is better, although smudges more.)
I hate this. (Not to be blunt, or anything.) This liner does have a few things going for it--it's very back and I like the stiff applicator. But, it smudges like nobody's business. You have to put it on and then sit without moving or blinking for several minutes or it transfers like crazy. To compound that, it is pretty waterproof and resistant even to makeup remover. So, once it smudges you're screwed in terms of cleaning it up again. I'm an old pro with liquid liner, so I don't think it's my technique. I wouldn't buy this again. There are better contenders in the drug store category for black liquid eyeliner.