I only bought this because Rimmel was out of their black eyeliner and this one had decent reviews. But after wearing it for several days, yesterday I especially noticed that after putting it on my lash line, there was what looked like smudged or runny marks on my bottom tear duct area. It looked like I had cried it off when I hadn't cried at all that day. It also doesn't go on as smoothly as I'd like. It will work for now until my Ulta stocks up their Rimmel black eyeliner again. Sigh.
This is a really good eyeliner for a eyebrow pencil! Would recommend it!
This is my only & first & favorite black eyeliner ! Its perfect except for when I apply it on my water line it wont stay .-___- But it still looks like its on my eyes , I need to firgure out how to make it stay !
Love it. I tightline with this, with the occasional waterlining. Excellent staying power for such an inexpensive product!
a nice, simple black eyeliner. it glides on with just the right consistency for me and stays put really well. its so cheap, so simple, does the job, and isn;t tested on animals. A++
being in the beauty bizz, you would think my all time favourite eyeliner would be, mac, smashbox, or something else that is more on the expensive side. but nyx has shocked me! i bought this from a store near me for $4.95 australian dollar. and it is amazing, i have bought eyeliners that have costed me $30-60 and havent been half as good as this! its creamy, and it stays on all day on your lash line. it does stay well on your waterline and tighline, but not aswell. go out and buy this product!
This eyeliner is a great alternative if you want something cheap and good quality. My eyes get really watery at times and this eyeliner stays on! I use it on my upper lash line and my waterline and it stays on for along time. Its creamy and has very nice pigmentation.
Overall I LOVE this eyeliner and would defenitly buy it again:)
Pros: The pencil liner is soft, easy to work with, and well pigmented..
Cons: The liner doesn't stay on my upper lashline or my water line for much longer than 3 hours.. it smudges easily and because it's so soft, when you sharpen it you lose product.
The colour of this eyeliner is pigmented and intense, but what I find great about it is that it is best for smudging. You can smudge it and still retain the intense colour.
For this reason, I wouldn't use it on my waterline - only on my upper and lower lash lines, and it is my go-to eyeliner for this.
The staying power is decent - it won't totally rub away by the end of the day. In fact I find it smudges out nicely during the day to create a more natural look (if that makes sense!).
A complete mess. Imagine black dye in vaseline on a hot summer day.