I used to love these liners and I still kind of like the black one, but I've realized that there are so many better eye liner pencils out there for the same price. I don't think the colors are too pigmented and also the glitter is almost invisible. The liner doesn't smudge, but I wouldn't say it lasts too long. I used to reapply it a couple of times a day when I was wearing it. All in all I don't hate the product, but I don't see any reason to love or to repurchase it.

Oh, my favorite everyday eyeliner, I just love Saturn grey. Its' soft but not too soft, you can do your eyes really quickly in the morning when you're running late :) the price is great, espacially when it's on sale, which happens pretty often. it brings great attention to your eyes without ever getting racoon eyes :)

These are very less likely to smudge, and if they do, it happens very rarely. I sometimes have to tug on them and my eyelid in order for it to apply, but otherwise, the liner looks very smooth and is quite self sharpening.

I'm pretty torn about this product, I love it AND I'm disappointed by it at the same time. I find that not all the colours apply the same for me, I have a few of them. Smoky Diamond, Brown Sugar, and Emerald are all wonderful... they apply smooth and with just the perfect amount of pop. But I also have Twilight Sparkle and Sugar Plum and these two leave much to be desired, they don't apply smoothly and the colours aren't as dramatic as I'd like them to be... Sugar Plum is barely visible on my skin!

I'll give them a 4 in the end, just because I love Smoky Diamond and Emerald so much.

First of all I don't wear much makeup, just a little bit to add a glowing touch to my complexion! Like famous makeup artist Bobby Brown philosophy "a natural look". This product is inexpensive and do the job, smooth on well, very softly, you don't need a sharpener, easy to use, nice package, a range of nice shades, safe to use on eye area, average longevity. I bought it dozens of this eyeliner in black and brown shades and will buy it over and over again! Nice product.

The black one is great, The colored ones, however, leave quite a bit to be desired. They just didn't pop and didn't glide on as smoothly as I prefer. I picked them up on sale for super cheap and would never ever pay full price for these at this point. Actually, I think I'd probably get more color by swiping a dollar bill on my upper lid. :/

I'm still on the fence with this eyeliner. The application is amazing. It's smooth like butter, with no tugging and amazing pigmentation. However, it smudges! I can only wear this on my upper lash line, due to the smudging, and it travels to my lower lash line. I don't know if i got a bad batch, but this didn't work for me. Too bad, because it didn't have glitter in it, and i purchased the waterproof version.

I really like this! I have it in brown, really easy and comfortable to apply and wear, looks natural and it lasts nicely..but it does smudge a little bit on me, and if I'm only wearing it on my top lids it will transfer to the bottom ones which isn't that attractive (although its not the waterproof one..which I now really want to try)

I can't say enough god things about this product!I've been wearing this eyeliner ever since I started wearing make up.It's the one thing I can't go without:Dlol!It's smooth,doen't crumble or ball up!It stays put nicely.I love love love this liner!!!It is a bit pricey,but Avon is ALWAYS having sales on it!!The best eyeliner everrrrrrr!!!!

Great eyeliner for a less dramatic look (I reserve my Urban Decay 24/7 for that). Good staying power and a reasonable price :) And cruelty free!