I thought this product was ok, not great nor bad. The only gel liners Ive tried are this one and Mac and they are pretty much the same quality. There is no "laqer" look with this one as it says though. It stays on well but I dont like how I have to go over and over my eye to get it dark enough. I find its harder to be precise with these type of eyeliners I prefer liquid ones way more.

I love this product and I hope that Loreal would never get rid of it. It is the best gel liner ever. It does not smudge whatsoever. I put it on around 6:00am and get home around 11pm, the liner looks just like you put it on in the morning. I also used a primer before applying the liner, I think that also helps a little bit with the staying power. If they ever get rid of this, I would haul like crazy and have hundreds of backup...lol :)

This makes the maybelline one look like crap. Seriously. This is amazing!!

I've tried a lot of gel liners. Mac, Bobbi Brown, Smashbox, etc.

And this one actually as good as my favorite gel liner - Bobbi Brown. It's a very true black. It says on all day. The application is smooth because of the creamy formula. And I like how it comes with a brush. The brush isn't half bad to apply eyeliner with. It's easy to control when you are drawing wings.

Good job L'oreal. I'm pleasantly surprised.

I actually just bought this product at walmart after seeing it on commericals and what not, Funny story that I actually ended up getting it for free because it was over $10 and walmart mistakenly priced the item at $8 (their mistake), Anyways I have not had the chance to use it yet but since some of the reviews are good I cannot wait to try it now!!

So I bought this based on this review this girl gave about this. She has a monolid and put this as one of the eyeliners she liked that didn't budge. However, for me in smudged. Sometimes it didn't smudge too much, but the point is it doesn't stay put like it should. I put my finger over it and the liner comes right off. This is after wearing it for hours. I do however like the packaging a lot. The brush comes with a cap and I totally loved that.

I'm just gonna stick with liquid liners. I noticed I had to put more effort into getting accuracy using gel liners.

I really love this liner. It goes on incredibly smooth and is very easy to correct and work with. The brush makes it so much easier for me to create the winged looked (something I wasn't very good at with the liquid or pencil). I have a firmer angle brush that seems to push the color around, but the softer one that comes with this is perfect. I can't wait to try other colors!

This gel liner is awsome! It goes on smoothly on the application,you got to apply two coat to make it more opaque,it last all day,perfect for any look! Love it!

o m g...this eyeliner is absolutely amazing!
I first bought it when I switched from liquid eyeliner to gel and i'll probably keep using it until it's discontinued.
I can't believe the negative reviews.. I honestly think anybody who dislikes this eyeliner doesn't know how to apply it.

PROS
-smooth, creamy and glides on so softly (I just use the provided brush)
-thick and highly pigmented
-does not smudge
-lasts the entire day...even sometimes when i've slept with it on
-the container dsnt waste any of the product & it's easily accessable
-available at almost every drugstore
-does not get chunky, clump or dry even though i've had it for a long time

CONS
-it's a little expensive for a drug store brand (not for me, but some people may find it a little more pricey!)

continued >>

This is my new favorite gel liner! I used to swear by the L'oreal HIP & the Physician's formula gel liners (both are great) but this lacquer liner blows those liners out of the water. It is super pigmented & ultra creamy so it glides on smoothly. No patchy application, flaking, smudging, or smearing with this liner. I've been using the brush that comes with it and I find that I can get the perfect winged liner look with it. I have nothing bad to say about this liner & I cannot wait to go buy all the other colors! I had been wanting to try the gel liners by MAC and/or Bobbi Brown for a while but now that I have discovered this I have no desire to stray from it. continued >>