Now I definitely do not understand the low rating on this color. This is a somewhat pigmented very light but kind of bright pink. Think of it as a bold baby pink color it looks perfect on fair skinned people or cool toned skin people. This was also my first color besides the creme brule a and I am in love with it. If you are a cool skin person or a light skinned person it will look great on you. It's somewhat of a bold colors so it will not take a lot to color your lips but is it is a pretty pink. Its like sugar frosting without the frostiness and is more bold. I would definately buy this color over and over.

On it's own this looks revolting too pale orangey makes me look dead but over a neutral lip liner - AMAZING it is a bit like my fave L'oreal Fairest Nude this way but more peachy and less pink. This is one of my faves of the Lip butter range.

i really wanted to love this. the color is great, and it seems like it would be hydrating (since they are lip "butters"), but that unfortunately did not work out. this highlights any dry spots, and seemed to make my lips DRIER after i took it off. may have to just throw this one away. shame because the color is great.

I'm surprised to see so much Creamsicle hate going on here, I actually quite enjoy the shade. I do have naturally fair skin so the lipstick is the perfect nude lip for me and I like the glossy finish.

Application isn't easy. I always apply a lip balm before using Creamsicle because on dry lips it does highlight imperfections. I also need two or three coats for it to become opaque which is much different than the other lip butters I've tried.

Out of the four that I own, this one is my least favorite- but that's not to say that it isn't a good product. I wouldn't pay full price for Creamsicle, but if I finish my tube and I haven't found another nude lipstick that I like, I'll repurchase it.

This was my first Revlon lip product.
As many haters as there are, I must say I like it.
I am a verrryyy pale girl, so this color didn't turn out bad at all.
It takes a few layers to really get the color out, but its okay i guess...
The packaging is cute :) but the square Revlon thingy at the bottom gets on my nerves. Just a bad habit. lol
A few negatives... The color does sink into the cracks and lines on your lips. It's annoying -.- It's moisturizing, at least....

I tried to like this shade, I really did. The color looks pretty in the tube but once you apply it on your lips, there really isn't much color. If you have chapped lips with dead skin on the lips, you should use a lip scrub before applying this product.

In general I love Revlon Lipbutters and have tried all the colours. I really thought I'd love creamsicle, but it has turned out to be my least favourite of the lot. I absolutely love creme brulee and bought creamsicle shortly after thinking it would be similar and suit my fair skin. I was very wrong. As others have already pointed out it seemed to stick to the imperfections and cracks in my lips and just kind of clumped in places instead of staying even across the lips. The formula felt thinner than some of the other Revlon lip butters. The colour was also terrible on me.. too pale and milky. I guess I should blame my poor colour choice but I'm really not sure who this lip colour is aimed at because if it looks bad on my fair skin I can only imagine what it will look like on darker skin tones. I really wished I'd bought a back up of creme brulee instead of wasting my money on this colour.

i really like the texture of the lip butters, this one in particular is much too light for my pigmented lips and made them look chapped, yuck, im sure it would be great on someone with light colored lips, but it looks bad on me

Lucky I got this on eBay for $15! Because I was very unhappy and disappointed in this colour! I'm a huge fan of the Revlon Colourburst lip butter range, but this one, was horrible. Worst coverage, applied it about 5 times, all the colour sinks right into the lines in the lips, small cracks ect... Not impressed at all... Would not recommend this to anyone, unless their lips are really pale.

Love! I have extremely pale skin and this is the only nude that looks decent on me!