This eyeliner really lasts until you take it off. I wear it from about 7 in the morning until 10 or 11 at night. It doesn't smudge or wear off.

It has a nice smooth texture, so it doesn't pull when you're applying. The built-in sharpener is good too. The eyeliner doesn't crumble or break off while you're sharpening it, like the Revlon Colorstay liners do. You can get a decent fine point for precise lines, or smudge (there's sort of a sponge for smudging at one end of the eyeliner. )

I just wish it came in more colors.

I absolutely love this eyeliner. I have bought many eyeliners over the years, and this is by far the best. It really does stay on for a long time. I forgot to take off my makeup one night, and i was surprised when i looked in the mirror to find it still there, just a bit smudged! This usually stays on the whole day with no smudging. Usually I have to swipe under my eyes multiple times a day to get rid of eyeliner that has started to disintegrate, but not with this one! Not even with 95 degrees outside with 80% humidity.! I recommended it to my friend, and she now swears by it too! I will definitely by this again and again.

The only bad thing i have to say about this is that you do have to wipe off the top layer before you use it again if you get eye shadow on it otherwise you don't get an intense enough color as you get with the first use.

This is a great product. It lasts for a long time and it doesn't smudge at all. Its easy to take off too. I use this first than a navy blue shadow to get a nice effect cuz i have brown eyes.

I love that this comes with a blending stump and sharpening point on the end. the eyeliner it's self did last my whole day but DID manage to find it's way below my eye. several times a day I need to wipe under my eye to make sure it wasn't there. i do like this in the end though.

The only reason why I purchased this was because the eyeliner that I usually would get (Maybelline's Unstoppable Onyx) was sold out. Ever since I discovered MUA, I would search up every makeup product that I'd consider buying and read about it. Well, this product here had pretty decent reviews and it claimed to not smudge and run.. Which I thought was great cause the Maybellines Unstoppable liner still smudged a tiny bit over time, but the staying power was pretty awesome (compared to other eyeliners that I've used in the past). Anyway, after trying this for the very first time, I noticed that it glided on very smoothly and was a very black black (which turned out to be the only thing that I liked about the eyeliner, unfortunately) I really wanted to love this eyeliner !! But it didn't work too well for me.. It smudged right away and I kept having to reapply which was a bummer.. And the lid for the smudger kept falling off which sucked cause it got all over my other cosmetics.. I definitely won't be repurchasing again.

so much for being infallible, it smudged in an hour, made me look like a raccoon :(

I did not care for this eyeliner. It looked like I had raccoon eyes before the day was even over. I didn't like the way that it went on. Won't be buying this again.

This made all my eyeliner dreams come true. I'd been avoiding pencil liners because they usually smudge, but this... THIS.

First off, the color is DARK DARK BLACK. Which is essential for me.
The packaging is amazing. It has its own squishy little smudger, a retractable thing, AND a little tip sharpener.

When applying it, it didnt rape my eyelashes. It also didnt leave that fleshy line, it always got right to my lashline. It glides on like a creamy dream, and it didnt smudge all day. I even would rub my eyes and it stayed. <3

This is the most perfect liner ever. I CANT FIND A SINGLE FLAW. BUY IT NAO.
Arigato~ continued >>

I purchased this in dark brown and I really, really like it. My only complaint is that sometimes it takes a little time to apply (maybe I need to warm up the liner a bit - i.e., between my finger tips?). Otherwise, it creates a precise line and it stays on all day and all night :) Unlike other products I've tried, it does NOT break. Highly recommended.

Yay finally my HG drugstore eyeliner!! I used to use revlon colorstsay, but that tugged on my lids so badly and was impossible to smudge when I wanted a softer look. So I picked this up on sale and it is FANTASTIC! Here's the key point though - you MUST set it with black eyeshadow or it WILL smudge, which is why I took of a lippie (use an angled brush to do this, and yes, it works even on your waterline). When you do set it, it stays put for the whole day! The smudger also works and is conveniently on the end of the liner, and you don't have to sharpen it because it's retractable. You can also use different colors to set the eyeliner, which gives a fun look (I'm wearing it right now and I set it with blue eyeliner :))