Worst mascara I ever bought! Both regular and waterproof ends turned into completely tar-like gunk after a few months of staying inside my makeup drawer and I haven't even used it yet! I tried reviving it by dipping into hot water and it still wouldn't budge. Waste of money.
HATE this!!! The clumpiness upon the first sight of the wand really upset me. Packaging really isn't that good, didn't lengthen or define my lashes, zilch. If you want good color payoff this is a nice thing to have, but otherwise really didn't like this.
I got this in brown, and honestly most of their products work like some of their more expensive comps, this however was horrible. Terrible coverage, clumpy upon opening for the first time, no defining, lengthening, nothing.
i will not be buying this product again, i love elf makeup but this mascara duo was a complete wast of money. when i first bought it i was very excited that it was only one u.s. dollar but after applying it i was so angry at myself for falling into the "it was only a dollar" trap. i was going to do a review on it for my youtube channel but its just not worth my time
This product was OK and I would probably buy it again because of it's low price. I do find it hard to try and wipe off the little clumpy bits on the brush but it does go on my lashes nicely. I actually have the brown one but I couldn't find any review pages for the brown one. I really like the regular side because it's not as clumpy as it is on the waterproof side in my mascara tube. It's a decent mascara but you could probably find better. If you're low on cash, buy this and see how it works for you.
I'm surprised by the negative reviews because this works perfect for me as an everyday mascara. It doesn't clump or flake (my major mascara pet peeves), is easy to layer without looking spidery, and it stays put without smudging for at least 12 hours. It gives a very natural appearance, so if you want super volume or length, you won't like this, but for a natural, feathery daytime or office look, you can't beat this for just $1.00.
Great for traveling since it's so cheap. I'm surprised at the negative reviews because it works great for me. It doesn't burn my eyes at all and both sides work great. My only complaint is that it can clump a little but that is easily fixable with a lash comb.
I love this mascara mascara over cat eyes from meybellin:)
really makes my eyelashes look longer and tapering.
with cheap price, young people like me can still be stylish with the elf product
I don't understand the many bad reviews. Usually my eyes become irritated after applying mascara, but that didn't happen with this brand. I applied the waterproof side to my lashes and was pleasantly surprised. My lashes are pretty black, separated, and look a bit fuller. I'll continue to purchase.
Edit: I'm glad I only gave it 4 lippies because it's rather hard to wash off!
Worst mascara I've ever tried! "You get what you pay for!"