Having only used Fresh Sugar's "Rose" in the past, I was looking for something that wasn't as bold that would work with my pale skin. I though that "Petal" would be the perfect MLBB color, but I was disappointed because it turned out to be much darker and reddish than I expected. I was hoping for a more sheer, light pink color, but unfortunately the formula was a lot thicker and more opaque than I would have liked.
Fresh has got a winner with their new shade, Petal! I'm a very pale NW15 with medium toned lips and this is absolutely a MLBB shade. It is slightly thicker than the Rose or Plum shades. Petal is more like Fresh's Honey in consistency. The shade is perfect!