I've had this lipstick for awhile now. I do like the color; there's nothing wrong with the pigmentation, nor the scent (smells fruity?), or even the packaging (it's not all that glamorous looks-wise, but it's $1). All these aspects of the product are just fine--meaning that they don't disappoint.
However, the texture of the lipstick is so drying and not moisturizing at all. But this is not uncommon with matte-like lipsticks.
The problem is the after-effect. After this lipstick fades, it leaves a sort of white residue on my lips (which is probably a combination of leftover product and my lipskin). My lips then looks very dry and even grey almost.
I just don't think that the ingredients are good for your lips.
Love love LOVE this lipstick. Not too pink, but just enough to stand out. Will repurchase for sure.
The lipstick is fantastic. though it is not super creamy, it doesnt dry out my lips. The color is pretty and pigmented. The package is useful though not pretty. I like it.
This lipstick is a slightly darkened blue pink with no shimmer. On me, this is in no way a dupe for MAC's Angel. Angel is alot softer and has a different finish whereas ELF's Classy is rosier and is more matte. This lipstick is great quality for $1. The feeling isn't too waxy and it glides on effortlessly. The lasting time is pretty average at around 2 hours. The packaging is super cheap plastic and has no weight to it. The lipstick can't be screwed all the way down which may cause it to be knicked at the side into the top of the lipstick. The scent is a super artificial fruity scent that may bother people who are sensitive to scented makeup but I can get by it.This color is great as an everyday pink. If it was a bit less rosy, I would wear it more often. For the great price, it is worth trying. If you are sensitive to strong scents, this wouldn't be the best product for you.
This is slightly creamier than e.l.f.'s lipstick in ''seductive''. It has a strong berry scent and taste which I really like and it is quite pigmented but it's just not very good. You have to press really hard for it to show up, it seems like it's made out of plastic. It doesn't last that long on the lips either. I dislike the packaging as well, it looks really cheap and it's really stiff and wooden.
This is a great lipstick for a dollar. I find myself reaching for it just about everyday. It's not extremely pigmented but that's fine with me because I prefer a more sheer lipstick for casual everyday looks. I've heard that this is a dupe for MAC Angel but I don't own Angel so I can't say for sure. I think the packaging is kind of cheap and tacky looking but the product itself is pretty good and it's definitely worth a dollar.
Ok so, being my usual ditsy self, i bought this product by sheer accident; my intent to the colour seductive. So naturally, when the lipstick arrived i was shocked by the berry-like colour. I assumed it was a mistake and so checked the website to realise that i'd pressed 'add to cart' on the wrong colour! A lesson to be learnt here- CHECK YOUR CART!
However, i LOVE this colour! I usually go for pale pinks, as i'm shy to lip colour (not eyes, i put all sorts on those!) but i'm so glad i didn't choose the right colour. It's amazing- the colour radiant, yet not overly prominent. For the price, in a nutshell, it's super. It tend to come off around the centre of the lips during eating, but i didnt expect a 12hour or whatnot staying power, especially due to the price. A simple re-application later and voelia! PERFECTION!
I wore this for the first time in awhile today and forgot how much I like it. It has a nice pale pink with a bit of blue in it. It's almost a MLBB...but more blue. It has a satin finish, but the color doesn't have the greatest pay off and it doesn't go on completely smooth. Sometimes there are chunks that have to be smoothed out, but otherwise the application is pretty good and I like semi-opaque pay off usually.
This works for me as a natural matte lipstick. The color is actually pretty close to my natural lip, so I can use this when not going for an overly made up look. I will say that it has staying power...I did a skin swatch and after soap/water and then a diaper wipe, I still had residue on my hand. Not sure if this is some sort of allergic reaction. But on the lips, it goes on creamy (if a bit thick) and has the slightest tingly feel.
The packaging is something I don't like. I would've preferred the color at the end of the stick and not just a tiny strip of color in the middle.
The best points for this; color and packaging. The color looked so beautiful in the tube. On me it is not opaque and rather sheer. It's very creamy and moisturizing...bordering on greasy. It does not last even up to 1 hour on me. On the first application, the entire stick broke off and fell. The packaging is sleek and pretty. The other downside is the strong fruity smell that I couldn't get past. e.l.f. has many amazing and worthwhile products, but this is one to pass on.