This is my all-time favorite liquid liner. It's virtually fool proof. It goes on easily & stays on all day. I was using MAC's Penultimate liner before I purchased this on a whim at the drugstore. Honestly, this liner is much better than Penultimate -- and much, much cheaper. You can't beat that!

Hands down THE. BEST. LIQUID. LINER I have ever try, everrr!!

I love the felt tip it gives me the neatest (is that the correct word?) application and I can control the wand really well, I also like the glossy finish it gives, and it's super black, I have yet to test its lasting power as I have only use it for little time... I have to use it a whole day in this weather... but I have yet to try a liquid liner better than this one.

I wasn't so pleased with this product.

I decided to buy this on a whim after hearing Juicystar07 (aka, blair) on youtube talk about how she loves this.

I found the formula to be incredibly streaky. I'd get random places on my lashline where it would be black, and then like black ink mixed with water to make it look like a gray.

You also don't get a lot of product, and the felt tip applicator absorbs most of the liquid liner.

I was disappointed in this product, & will try a new liquid liner soon.

LOVE this liquid eyeliner, I love gel liner but this is a great liner to use if your in a rush, this is my everyday eyeliner, will repurchase!

Hands down my favorite eyeliner! I was always terrified of using liquid liner because I knew it would be something I'd easily mess up!
The felt tip brush allows a smooth, easy, one stroke application! Rarely do I ever need to go over a second time. If you have shaky hands, this will definitely assist you with applying the liner.

Pros:
- the handle provides an easy grip
- long lasting, true black fomula (8 hours +)
- does not smudge
- dries quickly, but it is easy to remove
- does not flake
- no scent
- water proof
- well packaged
- the felt tip pen works wonders!
- perfect for doing a winged effect
- gives you a defined lash line

Cons:
- its hard to get a thin line with the applicator
- not for bottom lash line
- a slight bit glossy, which can also be a pro depending on what you're looking for.

I'm not really a fan of liquid eyeliner,but I prefer this design with the felt tip than I do with the brush.I have better control with the tip and this doesn't flake or crack as fast as some of the other liquid liners do,but by the end of the day it still has faded faster than some of my pencil eyeliners do.I rarely use this so I won't rebuy,but if your new to the different types of eyeliner and want to try a liquid one I would say to try this one out first.

I absolutely love this liner. I'm not sure how people are having a problem with this product. I've never had it flake on me and I use it everyday for - for the whole day. It's easy to apply, create the wing tip that seems to be popular and it's easy to take off. Sometimes I just rub it off with water if i'm lazy :P I think it actually lasts me a long while before I need a new tube.

It gets a little annoying when it starts to run out because I have to shake it to get the tip absorbed with product. It's like one of those felt pens where you have to shake to get any ink. But it always does come through for me.

I'm in Canada and I found that the price for this went up a few dollars 9.99 to 12.99 at shoppers drug mart.I went down to the states and it was MUCH cheaper (duh..) Regardless, it's cheaper than other brands such as mac or nars :P
Neways My HG!~

I ABSOLUTELY LOVE this product! I could never ever use liquid eyeliner. I shake horribly and it would end up looking like a mess on my eyes, but with this felt tip applicator, you have so much control of the placement. I'll never use a brush applicator again. Im totally sold on this product!

Ever since I fell in love with L'oreal eyeliners I regret not finding out about them earlier and spending all that money on BB and MAC. I bought this in 'Black Mica' and it is already an intense, deep, true black. I have the liquid eyeliner in Carbon Black and it is amazing also. Not only is the colour amazing, the felt tip is precise, and versatile and the line is budge-proof. I really like eyeliners that are able to create that crisp, clean eye-widening look...and this works for Asian lids as well!

I love the felt tip applicator. To draw a thin line, I gently pull back my outer eyelid towards my hairline, just a bit, and balance my elbow on the table while I start applying from the middle to the outer corner and then start at the inner corner towards the middle. Normally, I don't wear black eyeliner because I think it looks too harsh. But with this, I can make a really thin precise line and it looks very natural. There is just enough product saturated in the felt tip that I can complete one eye without dipping the applicator back into the tube. Lasts all day without flaking or smudging. One complaint: eyeliner closest to the inner corner sometimes disappear. Still, highly recommended.