Mine was streaky and not at all INTENSE black but comes off more gray. I love super dark black liquid eyeliner so this didn't work for me...

I really like this eyeliner, but the staying power is not that good. After a few hours it starts to smudge. The felt tip makes the application very easy, so it is good for make up beginners.

Firstly I LOVE this liner in the 'black' shade, it is my HG liner! Has been for years. But carbon is streaky. Like the last reviewer I have to put 2 coats on for it to look good. Skip this shade!!

I bought this liner after hearing youtube gurus rave about it...
Must say, i'm disappointed in it.
It streaks like crazy!!! I have to do one coat, let dry and repeat like three times! It actually goes on watery looking.

I prefer my gel liners over this.

I really wanted to like this eyeliner, but I just don't =(

This is my all-time favorite liquid liner. It's virtually fool proof. It goes on easily & stays on all day. I was using MAC's Penultimate liner before I purchased this on a whim at the drugstore. Honestly, this liner is much better than Penultimate -- and much, much cheaper. You can't beat that! continued >>

Hands down THE. BEST. LIQUID. LINER I have ever try, everrr!!

I love the felt tip it gives me the neatest (is that the correct word?) application and I can control the wand really well, I also like the glossy finish it gives, and it's super black, I have yet to test its lasting power as I have only use it for little time... I have to use it a whole day in this weather... but I have yet to try a liquid liner better than this one.

I wasn't so pleased with this product.

I decided to buy this on a whim after hearing Juicystar07 (aka, blair) on youtube talk about how she loves this.

I found the formula to be incredibly streaky. I'd get random places on my lashline where it would be black, and then like black ink mixed with water to make it look like a gray.

You also don't get a lot of product, and the felt tip applicator absorbs most of the liquid liner.

I was disappointed in this product, & will try a new liquid liner soon.

continued >>

LOVE this liquid eyeliner, I love gel liner but this is a great liner to use if your in a rush, this is my everyday eyeliner, will repurchase!

Hands down my favorite eyeliner! I was always terrified of using liquid liner because I knew it would be something I'd easily mess up!
The felt tip brush allows a smooth, easy, one stroke application! Rarely do I ever need to go over a second time. If you have shaky hands, this will definitely assist you with applying the liner.

Pros:
- the handle provides an easy grip
- long lasting, true black fomula (8 hours +)
- does not smudge
- dries quickly, but it is easy to remove
- does not flake
- no scent
- water proof
- well packaged
- the felt tip pen works wonders!
- perfect for doing a winged effect
- gives you a defined lash line

Cons:
- its hard to get a thin line with the applicator
- not for bottom lash line
- a slight bit glossy, which can also be a pro depending on what you're looking for.

I'm not really a fan of liquid eyeliner,but I prefer this design with the felt tip than I do with the brush.I have better control with the tip and this doesn't flake or crack as fast as some of the other liquid liners do,but by the end of the day it still has faded faster than some of my pencil eyeliners do.I rarely use this so I won't rebuy,but if your new to the different types of eyeliner and want to try a liquid one I would say to try this one out first.