I purchased this hoping it might replace my Covergirl LashExact which I love but it's started to flake on me. I was sorely disappointed as it wasn't even half as good for me.
I found the formula too liquid, it took ages to dry and seemed to stick to my lashes in such a way that they all joined together and formed a few big lashes instead of lots of separated volumous ones. It smudged under my eyes and made them kinda sensitive but it didn't flake :-P
I like the packaging but I'm a fan of a wand that stays in one place instead of bending around while I run it through my lashes.
I wont be buying this ever again, I used it twice and now it's just sitting at home and will never get used.

I don't like how flexible the head is, it's almost impossible to put back into the tube. The mascara it's self is not very voluminous and it flakes easily, would never purchase again and I regret buying this.

Wow I am really surprised at the negative reviews on this mascara. I really do like this mascara alot and I have tried sooooooooooooo many.
I love how it makes my lashes look so dark and defined. I don't find it to clump. I will defintely purchase again for those days I don't want to use my Hypnose which is $27.00 (gulp...lol)

This is one of the worst mascaras I have ever tried. It does not add any volume or lenght. Basically it does nothing. The pink colour of the packaging is nice but the actual tube feels very cheap. I have difficulty putting the brush back into the tube and getting it out.

Eh, I'm kind of disappointed with this mascara. I expected volume since, well, it says volume. I got zero volume. The only decent thing it did was seperate my lashes, but that wasn't what I was looking for. I expect more out of this mascara since it's one of the most expensive mascaras Maybelline sells ($6-$7 compared to the normal $5). Not buying again.

This mascara was disappointing to me because I expected a lot more OOMPH than I actually got. I have been using Loreal Voluminous religiously for about two years now, so I opened my new tube of this to try it on yesterday, and I found that it gives my lashes the great length that Voluminous does not, but, contrary to its name, it does not give me VOLUME, which is a major problem. Another reason I gave this a 3 is because the very black shade is actually great at making my lashes look even darker, and also the brush prevents clumps so I was impressed.

I have super long lashes, but I like them to look thicker and fuller. This masara is great for anyone looking for a definicils dupe IMHO.

I got this mascara free with an eyeliner that I was buying. I like to get extra length with my mascara, and I had to put on a million coats to create any length. I didn't have any problems with clumping, but the flexible brush was horrible, and SO hard to get back in the tube. More than once, the brush bent all of a sudden when I was trying to put it back in causing me to get mascara all over my hand. Threw it away mid-tube, won't ever buy this one.

Maybelline has the worst mascaras I've ever tried. This one was no exception. Clumpy lashes, the brush bends too much when I put it back in the tube, it smears, etc.

I'm too lazy to return it, though. I'll keep it in my emergency kit in case I have to spend three days trapped in the wilderness or something.

This one ain't got nothing on its green big sister. It's blah, nothing great, not that great at separation, and it gives terrible panda eyes. Will not be repurchasing.

I don't know why this mascara has such a negative rating? it works great for me! i like it even more than Diorshow and that's saying a lot! It gives me long thick lashes without any clumps. It's a very nice dark color and "defines" my lashes, just like it's name. The hot-pink tube is too cute as well! I will def. buy again when I run out