This is probably one of the worse mascaras I've used next to anything by Maybeline. It did absolutely nothing for my lashes. It barely colored them but certainly did not lengthen or curl them. A waste of $5!
Generally speaking, this is a rather good mascara. I'm typically a volume girl, but this one had an on-pack free Exaggerate black e/liner and I was intrigued by the curl and length claims, so I picked one up.
It doesn't volumize (though it doesn't claim to so no fault to them) but it does separate my lashes and make them all feathery without any clumps. Quite good for anyone wanting that natural defined look. I can't say anything about the curling aspect (how do you measure that anyways?) but still a good find.
A great d/s mascara. Modestly thickens, definitely lengthens. Comes off easily and barely flakes, if at all.
It wasn't until I used it for a while (and then went back to Estee's More than Mascara) that I realized how good it actually was-it grows on you.
It's great for making lashes look better, but not so dramatic that you can't use it during the day.
I love this mascara. I bought it in black =) Cheap drugstore price, but awesome quality. It really separates and elongates your lashes! The formula doesn't clump either! I think it's great even for everyday use, it makes your lashes look naturally beautiful.
i love this mascara! I like the natural look and this mascara is VERY NATURAL looking, but its not bad because it still lengthens and seperates very well. my new favorite for sure!
Gave this a 2 for price--compared to other Rimmel mascaras, this is a bit more expensive. Packaging's a 4--dark lavender labeling on black tube looks sophisticated, but the tube is rather long, just shorter than those from L'Oreal mascaras. Still, I love this product. Lengthens lashes slightly and lasts at least 14 hours on me [then again, I don't cry--this is non-WP]. No problem with clumping, smearing, smudging. Stays well on lashes yet easy to remove--with non-greasy makeup remover plus face cleanser. Hope Rimmel keeps making this. Will repurchase if the mascara and formula stay.
Well all i seem to be doing nowadays is writing mascara reviews...my HG mascara has been discontinued so i have been testing many many new ones... my lashes are on the thick side..sorta short and stick straight ..pointing down... i curl my lashes first ... i dont like to curl my lashes after because that does alot of damage to your lashes..i read alot of reviews of people that actually apply thier mascara and then curl thier lashes..for some reason when i have tried to curl them after my mascara half my lashes get ripped out...anyhow...i use shisheido mascara base prior to applying mascara... i curled my lashes then put on my base..waited for it to dry and then applied this ..and WOW.. NO CLUMPING .. really defined and separated each individual lash and such a dark glossy black..i love it..i think this is my new HG mascara..i have no idea why this isnt getting rave reviews....maybe its the mascara base i use first... i am going to try it without the base to see the difference...i highly recommend this for women that have to use a curler ...my curl stayed 100 percent ...it worked great on my lower lashes as well ...i think my search is over... at the time i bought this i also got 6 other types of mascara..i will test those and then make my final decision... if you want Tammy Faye Baker lashes i dont recommend this... use the YSL Faux Cils...
If you want a mascara to lightly tint your lashes, then this is great. If you want it to volumize, thicken, or enhance your lashes in any way, then forget it with this mascara. I tried it with and without a primer and each time it looked the same. You could get the same results with Vaseline on your lashes. A waste of money.
yuck! this mascara made my long straight eyelashes droopy and clumpy, even when i curled them again after applying. i will not be repurchasing!
I have reviewed previously on the brown version; in my opinion brown does more for lenght, separation and curling than the black one, i could notice this the very first time i used the black one (I was using brown for some time by then). Neverthless a great mascara, i will repurchase.