Love these pencils. I had been buying Lauder and Lancome pencils for YEARS and then started buying MAC. This pencil blows them out of the water. My only complaint is the range of colors.

The wear was great and it came off easily with my regular MU remover.

I love this eyeliner!! It stayed on all day! Didn't even have to do any touch ups! Its a MUST HAVE!!! Best eyeliner I've ever used!

This is the best eye pencil. I wear liquid eyeliner on my eyelids and this eye pencil on my waterline. The price is reasonable. This eye pencil is very pigmented. It is smooth like silk. It doesn't irritate eyes. It doesn't smudge. This eye pencil is easy to use. I love this eye pencil so much.

Purchased because of the reviews. But it was hard to control- I like wet n wild liquide so much better ffor obtaining a great line. This product is a disappointment!

Tried the black. Fell in love. Went back and bought all the colors. LOVE THEM ALL!! Yay!

Absolutely amazing cheap eyeliner

Goes on darker than any affordable liner

Doesn't run or smudge too much

It does feel a bit weird in the eye but its not that bad.

Don't ever buy an expensive liner again.

First off I have sensitive eyes anyway but I definitely want to reiterate: don't put this on your waterline if you are at all nervous. IT BURNS. A LOT. ;-;

Beyond that tiny quibble (I have camphor ash for my waterline), this stuff is incredibly nice. I bought it on a whim and was shocked when I tested it on my hand: incredibly smooth, glides right on, DARK. Nice staying power, and if you move REALLY fast you can smudge it up a little--this is a must for me as I prefer a soft line to a hard one.

It's so soft the downside is that it's really hard to taper it off, and I am going through it faster than I usually do--having to resharpen every couple of applications if not every time. Definitely worth it for the price, however.

When I first saw this product, I immediately thought of the Urban Decay 24/7 liners. I had Zero and to be completely honest.. I thought it was a little too hyped up. It was good and all but I thought.. for $17, I thought it would be better. So I bought this, used it the next day, and boy did I fall in love! This has to be the richest black pencil eyeliner ever! And it is soooo creamy, more than the UD's Zero. I usually never put liner on my waterline because it fades within 30 minutes, but I tried this and didn't have to touch up for hours! The best part about it is I do not have to tug at my eye at all to create a beautiful line or wing! And this liner gives you enough time to work with to smudge or create a base for eyeshadow before it locks the color in place.. I also have the brown and it is so true to color, so rich and deep! And for the price, I think I got them at Walgreen's for about $5 and some change, what a great price!!

This is probably the best drugstore eyeliner I've tried -- even better than my beloved Cover Girl LiquiLine Blast. Actually, I like it even better than the Urban Decay 24/7 Liner, which is of course twice the price. It glides on really easily and doesn't smear; it's perfect for working into the top lashes to make a lush-looking lash line. Definitely a must-try!

Great product, glides on very easily. Very comparable to UD 24/7. The black one is very pigmented. But as other members have mentioned, this makes my eyes all blurry and teary. Can't apply it on the water line either. I don't understand why. If it wasn't for that, I'd buy again for sure.