Mac feline/smolder, Stila kajal, UD zero all got nothing on this baby! Absolutely fabulous liner! VERY black and creamy! The trick is to wait about 15 secs to set it with a black shadow and its not going anywhere for days! (ahha not that I leave my eyeliner on that long, but u get my drift). Don't waste your money on other black liners, go pick this one up! Def a good drugstore buy.
For the last few years my go-to pencil liner has been Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal, but lately my eyes have been watering a lot and the liner has been either A. wearing off or B. slipping down my undereye area..and that's really annoying and not fun. So after I used up the last bit of my Rimmel, I went out to get a new pencil and I found the Milani Liquifeye and it is amazing! I have been wearing it daily on my waterline and even occasionally on my lashline (where I generally use only gel) because it's SO creamy and it doesn't fade or smudge off. I even wore it to a concert and a party last night from about 5pm until 3am with no touchups and it still looked great (not perfect, of course, but great) when I removed my makeup before bed! I love this so much. I haven't tried to sharpen it yet, but I do see that as being a possible problem since the pencil is very soft. But overall, at this moment, this has HG status for me.
Edit: I've sharpened it twice since this review and I have not had a single problem. I usually have problems with the tip breaking off before it's as sharp as I want, but this one is amazing. My mom actually stole it from me last week because she likes it more than her Clinique. They're definitely comparable to UD 24/7 pencils (a little creamier and easier to apply, even) I just wish the Milani had the color selection of UD. Overall, amazing eyeliner and it's definitely HG status.
Awesome drugstore eyeliner. It is a pencil, but glides on just like a liquid eyeliner. I highly recommend this for those of you that like to line your waterline.
I didn't care for this product. It caused my eyes to water a lot.
I have been wearing this liner in black for a couple of weeks and I love it. It goes on very creamy but sets and last a long time once it's dry. It does fade throughout the day but it's not noticeable to me until the end of my work day which is a plus! I will definitely be buying this pencil again and I will definitely have to try other colors.
I love this eye liner pencil. I gave it a 4 star because it does smudge a little, not that much, but still a little. Very creamy and goes on easily. Would purchase again.
It's another one of those creamy liners that are almost like gel liners in pencil form. Glides on easily and opaquely without any tugging and stays put after it sets. Overall, it's a pretty great drugstore eyeliner.
I'm giving it a 4, because it's almost too soft. You have to sharpen this, and it's such a hassle to clean off the cream part, which always sticks to the blade. The pencil almost never has a sharp tip, because it's so soft. It's almost impossible to get a thin line, unless you use a brush or something to shape it.
That being said, this is a great pencil to line the waterline or tightline, and it doesn't smudge or fade on me that much, especially compared to most other eyeliners I've tried.
Just purchased it today, but i really really love it thus far :)
Cheaper than UD 24/7 is a plus... i paid about 7.99 at walgreens.
When I wear black eyeliner, I use Wet N Wild's Megaliner in Black on my top lashline because it gives a nice dark sharp line. However, I wear this on my lower waterline and also on my top lashline near the inner corner of my eyes (not putting liquid liner there!)
This has great pigment. A nice dark black. This is not for the faint of heart. It also is easy to apply. My L'Oreal Hip Truth Cream Eyeliner in Black is what I was using for my waterline and a bit on my top lashline before...and I must say that this lasts a bit longer. This pencil fades during the day on my waterline, though not completely, so I must touch up during the day once.That is why I took a lippy off. However, this pencil is faster in the morning which is a big deal to me. I guess because I rarely use this to line my entire top lashline, I do not need to constantly sharpen it like others do. I have this pencil in brown, which I use for my entire eye so to get a good line on my top lashline I need to sharpen it more.
This product sets quickly and lasts for a longtime. I even wore and cried and it still held up.