This is a bad product but for completely different reasons than listed below. It did not smudge at all even when I tried to seconds after I put it on which was a problem because when I use this product with eyeshadow on my lid it drags and creates a jagged line that you can't correct with a qtip like I can with Bobbi Brown gel liners. You also can't use it on the water line because it will not dry, when it comes in contact with that damp skin it just washes away. So this product would be awesome for someone who doesn't wear eyeshadow and doesn't want to line the water line. I've heard that if you store it upside down it won't dry out as much.
Terrible liquid liner! I got this in blackest black, it does not give an opaque black line! I had to go over it 3 times to get a dark line...and it only lasted an hour before it smudged!!! Don't waste your money. The tip is really hard too.
If you like liquid pens, get the Stila Stay all day waterproof liquid liner pen. Its twice the price, but its very black, you only have to sweep it over once, and it gives you the perfect cat eye in seconds! Plus the cat eye tips stay on for over 12 hrs, and i've even gone swimming with this liquid liner on. Hands down, the best.
I love it! Lasts all day! Doest move! Got it in black and its true black. Only cons are its hard to do a straight line, or maybe i just dont have a steady hand. Also the tip of the pen is kind of hard so i have to turn the pen sideways. Other than that, awesome product. :)
This isn't very pigmented, but I tried it after using MAC's gel pot, and I find it way easier to use. The revlon crayon's are even easier to use, but they come out too dark for me. I want an extra effect that's barely noticeable.
This easily dries out. I've only used it for a week, not even everyday, and it ran out on me... even if i tap on it. The pigmentation and tint is bad. And it smudges. The worst mascara...
I went through two "pens" of this product. The first pen I bought (actually it was a free gift with a Revlon eye palette, otherwise I wouldn't have touched it) was fantastic - the liquid flowed freely through the "felt-tip" wand, and it was super easy to get a nice clean line. It didn't last very long with daily wear - two or three months, perhaps. That and the fact that the black has a slight green tinge, would have been my only complaints, but...
The second pen I bought suffered the same malady as many of the other reviewers' seem to have - it was dry and the product hardly flowed. I had to wet it with water or saliva every time I used for the first few weeks, until it started flowing of its own accord. Old product? Bad batch? Who knows - it definitely put me off, and I went to a Shiseido cream eyeliner. When it's good, it's great, but when it's bad, it's horrible - won't repurchase.
product barely comes out, color was called "blackest black" and deifnitely was not! i would never buy this product again
This is the worst eyeliner I've ever used! I've used pen type eyeliners before that I liked, but I wanted to try this one because it was part of the colorstay collection, and I like my eyeliner to last all day. Yeah...it was hard, the product doesn't even come out on my eyelids, not even close to being black. This stuff just sucks, and I hate that I wasted my money on it!
I'm really surprised to see that people don't like this more! I am a fan of the "eye pen" because I like a nice clean line and I HATE smudging on the crease of my eyelid. This pen is easy to use. I have it in black, and it is nice and pigmented. It does not smudge, stays put all day. I can achieve that classic bombshell eye make up look that I love. I used Victoria's Secret eye pen in the past and this is very similar. The price was fair, not too expensive. Revlon does not test on animals and that is a wonderful thing!
Not pigmented enough for me unfortunately... I'm a big fan of their original Liquid Liner, but this doesn't even come close to that in the quality! Too bad.