To be fair I have given this eyeliner more than one chance. I retried it thinking that years have past and I couldn't for the life of me remember why i stopped using it.. Then when purchased again it dawned on me.. It lacks pigmentation and the products consistancy is so off that its crazy. The applicator/ felt tip was the most hard/ ruff thing that i've ever come in contact with in an eyeliner. Even if i wanted to I couldn't possible give this an A for effort. geez Revlon what gives?!

I do not understand positive reviews as well, maybe I get the bad one? It is watery. The color is not intense. And it tends to fade throughout the day. I will definitely not buy it again.

So I bought this when I ran out of my Mac Liquidlast liner and this is supposedly a Mac dupe...think again. I don't understand the positive reviews? Maybe I got a faulty product. It's not an intense black and actually looks like a dark grey when it's supposed to be black. As someone else mentioned here it has a tendecy of rubbing itself off if you try to apply over it to get it darker. Its as if its too watery. It fades a lot throughout the day and is definately not worth 11 bucks; I wouldn't repurchase under any circumstances even if it were free. If I were to buy a liquid liner from a drugstore again it would be Almay.

My first liquidy eye liner and I keep going back to it, I tired maybelline and bobbi brown gel liners but I keep going back to this , what i like most is that its easy to wash off at the end of the day and easy to clean up a mistake, which usually happens when I do a flicked eyeliner. but it doesn't smudge or fade throughout the day- in my experience.

This product is my favorite liquid eyeliner and I've tried them all. I'm one of those girls who overindulges in her winged eyeliner. Being Asian, just lining doesn't define enough for me. I need a vivid, black, sharp line and a slight wing and boy, does this product deliver!
One of these babies last me about three months' worth of every day lining and the color and the staying power is perfect every time. My only grip with it is pretty personal. The applicator loses its stiffness in a couple weeks, so I grow accustomed to the looser, softer tip. When I open a new package, the applicator is hard and stiff and doesn't pick up as much product as I want. But I suck it up.
A tip- I noticed this and Almay's black eyeliner(comes in a packaging with a white handle, not their Intense i-Color ones) are pretty much identical products, which makes sense because Revlon is Almay's parent company. But Almay's has more product- a .2 fl oz difference and it's actually a dollar cheaper at my local drugstore.

Hate this product. The brush is too small and too firm. You have to dip into the product after each stroke because not enough product gets on the brush. Also, the product has the tendency to erase itself if you brush too much in one spot. Also, when my eye watered the product completely came off. I wouldn't waste my money on this product ever again.

I bought this in Charcoal, but the colour is nearly black and is quite intense, so not exactly what I was looking for. I find I get a softer look from my black Fluidline! It is fairly easy to apply, though the brush is perhaps a little on the thick side, but I have still been able to vary the thickness of the line. The finish is matte, and I would say that the line lasts longer than from my Fluidline - it is more solid by the end of the day, but there can still be some smudging (I have oily eyelids). Not sure if I would repurchase - I am still on the lookout for a less intense colour.

I bought this on a whim, honestly not expecting much. After a couple of uses I was astounded at the quality of the lines I was achieving. As I was nearing the end of the product I decided to by MAC's liquid eyeliner assuming that it would be far superior. Alas, it wasn't (the lines were watery and imprecise in comparison & the colour less pigmented) and I will never again stay from my Revlon Colorstay liquid eyeliner. continued >>

Not bad- did not make my eyes sting, and did not run all over my eyes. The black is really intense, though, and the product comes with a thick brush- I really need a more subtle liner than this one. I am not totally crazy about the Cleopatra/Ronnie Spector/Amy Winehouse look that this liner keeps giving my face. Not a terrible product, though- halfway decent for what it is.

This was my first liquid liner, i bought it since i heard so many good things about this product. but honestly this eyeliner's brush gets messed up if you use it too long. Now i can only apply thick lines on my upper lashline. you can't apply thin lines with this eyeliner. this eyeliner's brush is really thick. I am going to try other liquid eyeliners instead!