Good stuff, blends beautifully and is easily smoked out. It glides and doesn't tug at all. Very nice opaque color. One of the best eyeliners I've used and I'm usually a liquid liner type of girl.

Wow! I love this eyeliner. It is a good as a department store brand. It is so smooth and lasting, plus I love the dark black. I highly recommend...

I purchased this after watching a review from DulceCandy87 on youtube. I love the smoothness, the intense color, & especially the price ( $6.50 @ Wal-Mart). I've heard that it's comparable to MAC's Smolder, but I've never tried it. I do have Blacktrack Fluidline & Feline eyeliner and I find myself reaching for the Loreal pencil more. continued >>

The best pencile liner I have ever purchased I have tried everything from Avons glimmerstick to este lauder and none comes close to working or looking as good as this brand. Doesn't budge smudge or fade and glides on smoothly and the cap stays on in my make up bag so no mess either ;)

This is the best eyeliner that I've tried. I have lancome's waterproof and clinique's waterproof and they don't even compare to this one. This eyeliner does not smudge or stray. I'm asian and have very oily skin and this lasts me all day. Love love love it.

ok so this is by far thee best eyeliner i have ever used in my life. its so rich, so creamy, so dark and black. my god, its the perfect eyeliner. before loreal, i was using almay, which is amazing as well but wasnt dark enough for me, plus it wasnt the easiest to apply. i mean the intensity is INCREDIBLE. then to top it off, i go over it with Carbon (mac e/s) to set it and make it even darker and it lasts ALL night! best eyeliner in the world, hands down!

I swatched this against Urban Decay Zero, and WOW I was blown away! The Loreal pencil was 3x darker than Urban Decay! And I thought that the UD one was as black as it can get! After letting the swatches dry on the back of my hand, I rubbed them with my finger. The UD pencil smeared a lot while the Loreal one stayed in place. I was super impressed! I love to wear this Loreal eyeliner with Dior "Black Out" mascara for that super intense black on black look :)

Loving this so much -- the deep intensity of a liquid, the ease of a pencil. The marketing is spot-on for this. I use it with a light touch for daily wear and more heavily for shows or evenings out. Fantastic pigmentation, fantastic lasting power. I've had no problems sharpening this to a precise point. My ony complaint is I wish they'd make this in more colors. This one is a makeup bag staple for me!

I got this eyeliner in a bonus with a mascara that i bought, and im so happy they did that because i tried it and im in love with it, it give a RICH and REALLY dark black, It stays for LONG! Its kinda pencil with liquid like they say in the name, and i LOVE it I recommend it for sure!

Love it! Bought the black after reading the reviews on here. I got it for $8.99 at CVS. Same price as my prior favorite Neutrogena eyeliner. I now have a new favorite!