It's a good eyeliner really dark black....smudged on me though. It's good to apply it to make another eyeliner darker but on it's own it smudges on me. I could get the same w/ a cheaper one. Sticking to blacktrack fluidliner.....
Best black eyeliner pencil ever. I've used this for years and wear it almost every single day. GREAT
My HG eyeliner. It doesn't smudge, but when I apply it I can blend it enough so that it looks natural. One application in the early morning lasts until I go to bed.
It's also the perfect shade for me; dark enough to make my eyes really stand out and not so dark that it makes them look small.
Initially the price can seem a bit expensive, but the product definitely lasts long enough that I don't have to re-buy it for a while (at least 6 months).
Love this eyeliner. I have repurchased this 4 times already, although I have been using it less now that I use fluidline.
But if you like pencils, this is the one to get. It does not smudge, and has relatively good staying power.
This eyeliner is okay, its a bit hard to sharpen. I think MAC fluidliner is alot better.
This was my first time using eyeliner and I thought this pencil was great. I can make thick lines or just lightly line my eyes fairly easily. It's a pencil so it's not waterproof but you definitely need an eye makeup remover to get all the color off without rubbing your eye area like crazy. The saleswoman told me I couldn't use a regular pencil sharpener for this pencil so I bought the MAC sharpener for like $3. I've had no problems with the pencil breaking when I sharpen it.
I switched to fluidline in blacktrack but I still love and use this eyeliner. But the only problem I have with this is the sharpening part. If u want this to be like dark dark black just go over it once more. I had a problem with it smudging and smearing until I started using Urban Decay Potion Primer. Just cant find a good sharpener to sharpen. Also, I heard before u sharpen eyeliner such as this that are cakey kinda ...just put the pencil in the freezer for two minutes then sharpen to get a perfect point. It works for a while until u need to just get a new pencil.
This is the only eye pencil I found so far that doesn't smudge. Very soft touch, doesn't not irritate my eyes. Highly recommended!
It's a great eyeliner pencil. It's easy to apply,it does not smudge, and the color is great! I can use it to draw thin line or thick line easily. I've had shiseido eye pencil before, and it didn't stay on very long. A lot of users had problem with sharpening this pencil, but I would recommend you to get a MAC eye pencil sharpener. It works well with the creamy texture of the pencil. I would buy this product again.
I bought this thinking it would be an amazing liner, since most MAC products are amazing. Unfortunately, I was very disappointed. When I put it on, it stayed for a little while (an hour and a half, two at most) and looked okay (the color was a rich black that looked great) but then it began to set beneath my waterline and make my wide eyes look very droopy. I also had this pencil in Stubborn Brown, which is a ton better than Engraved is. Like others had mentioned as well, this liner on the top of your eyelid has absolutely no staying power and does smudge easily. Also, it's very hard to sharpen the pencil for some reason, always breaking. And for the price, these pencils go fast just because you have to keep sharpening the ever-breaking point. Oh, and as a fair warning, this is not a carry-everywhere eyeliner either. The cap constantly fell off on mine, drawing all over my purse. :( Still haven't found my HG liner..