This is a good option for asian girls with hidden double eyelids or single eyelids as it glides on so easily and doesn't smudge. I find this creamier than Bobbi Brown.
While this cream liner is indeed smudge-proof, it is however NOT budge-proof, so anyone with a tendency for rubbing her eyes, like I do when my eyes water, please take note. It does come off slightly onto your kleenex or finger.
Overall, it's worth having one or two of these in your makeup kit.
I've been using this for a few weeks now and I love it! The gel liner is much easier to use than a liquid liner and goes on so smoothly. The best part is that it lasts and stays put. I'd been using pencil liners previously and don't think I'll go back to them. The small jar will last you a long time.
This is a great product. I'd been resisting fluidlines for a long time, mainly because I didn't want to invest in a brush as well. I'd been sticking my my faithful Teddy eye kohl for years. But I finally jumped on the bandwagon and it is worth it! Every girl needs a black eyeliner for her nights on the town and this one is the best she can hope for. It stays put and is a simple matte black. I don't find this too subtle or natural, like other seem to, because it is black and does have the pristine appearance of liquid eyeliner which, in my opinion, never looks subtle. But I think it is great and campy and lovely!
I love it so much! This stuff make a perfect thin line and look very natural on my eyes when I have mascara!
I've been wanting MAC to come out with a gel eyeliner like Bobbi Brown has. I'm sooo glad they finally did cause I like this in Blacktrack. It doesn't smear even with my oily eyelids.
I've been wearing cat eyes since I was old enough to wear makeup, and this product is the best black eyeliner by far. Yesterday my allergies were bothering me and my eyes started to water~ The liner stayed put!! I couldn't believe it, were it any other liner I've used in the past, it would have ran and smeared all over my face, (including the so called "waterproof" ones). I would definatly buy this product again. It's a bit pricy, but a little goes a long way, and the look and performance is well worth the price.
I recently purchused this eyeliner, and to my surprise, it actually is very nice. The liner stays on my inner rims for about 2.5 hours before I feel the need to reply. Also, it has the same black intensity as MAC's Smolder pencil, only in a different, more versitile form. The only major con with this product, that i have experienced so far, is that you need to have an extra brush for it. I use a super small sponge-tip applicator for my inner rims, and an angled brush from mac for under my lashes on on the top lid. Overall, this is a great buy, and I recommend it to anyone.
Overall a good e/l but its not smudgeproof. Within an hour and a half it has smudged and is traveling south. Also too much hassle for something that doesnt to what it says.
I absolutley LOVE this!!!! I just bought it a few days ago and it is much easier than any liquid liner I've ever used. The gel makes a smooth line and it stays on all day, I even cried and it stayed!! I will be purchasing in all the different colors!! :D
Wonderful eyeliner! Matte rich black that can be used for many different looks. Stays all day and stays true black. Very light mousse-like texture. Will repurchase.