I generally adore BeneFit products, and while this mascara applies well, it smudges too quickly for me. They recommended I try Shelaq over the top, but I'm already using too many products. I just want a mascara that doesn't make me look like a panda.
this mascara does do a great job lengthening - however, it managed to smudge on me even though i put on kiss me mascara as a final coat to seal the color (which usually works for me). i am very smudge-prone, so i'm sure this wouldn't be the case for many girls. it also made my eyes itchy and didn't thicken very much. so if you have thick lashes and aren't smudge prone you should go for this. if you're less fortunate, try something else.
I really like this mascara. i would give it 5 lipsticks, but the brush is just too big. I have to use a mascara with a more tapered brush first (Px False Eyelashes), and then I put Bad gal on top and it really adds alot of length and drama. I hate big brushes, makes a mess!!! Would definetly buy again, though not from a dept store-I buy my high-end stuff of ebay-way cheaper:)
LOVE this mascara ! Adds lots of depth and length to lashes. Several coats and WOW - unbelievably pretty. Beware of using any oil based creams above lids OR under your eyes when wearing this, however, or it will leave smudges.
Edit: Stopped using. When i purchased the second tube it was clumpy and flaked. Not good at all.
Ooh, I love this mascara! The brush makes me feel like Alice in Wonderland, it's so huge, I have to laugh whenever I see it. But the mascara lengthens and thickens, gives super coverage, and doesn't clump. Smudged a little under extreme conditions (kissing a cute boy) but not otherwise ;) Comes off easily with eye makeup remover. Love it!
LOVE this mascara. It gives you long, gorgeous, diva lashes! Not cheap, but it is worth the price. Would definitely repurchase.
This is a very natural looking mascara. If you want dramatic lashes, skip this one. I use this occasionally but I would never buy this again because its nothing special.
I tried this mascara and loved the thick black lash it gave me. It is a little hard to take off, but would be great for wearing out dancing.
This mascara smudges after a few hours. It does the job as far as lengthening, however I do not think it thickens as well as other inexpensive brands. I don't think I've ever had problems with smudging until I tried this mascara.
This is slowly but surely becoming one of my HG mascaras. As others have noted, both the wand and the tube are very large. You're definitely getting your money's worth with this product, because it lengthens in a way one really wouldn't expect. It made my lashes so incredibly long and noticeable that I was almost tempted to remove it and just use a lighter hand. I decided against doing that and later in the day, a friend asked if I was wearing fake lashes! So if you're after dramatic, super long, dark lashes, this is your best bet. I don't have intense smudging, but by the end of the day, there are definitely a few smudges beneath my eye. These are fortunately only noticeable when I take a real close look in the mirror, but your mileage may vary... if raccoon eyes really bother you then you may want to be careful with how much Bad Gal you actually use!