i have this eyeliner in this color and 1L. i switch off using them depending on how i feel like doing my makeup. i really like these eyeliners. i wouldn't say that its waterproof but it does last really long. i use it to line the top of my eyes, and it looks great. when the point dulls down it can be a little hard to get it on, and you need a good quality sharpener to sharpen it, otherwise it will continue to break when sharpening it. its a great eyeliner for people who need long lasting makeup.

2L has been my favorite eyeliner ever since I purchased it! It's a lighter brown compared to Black Coffee from Lancome, but you can definitely make it a darker brown if you go over the line you created. I actually went for a swim and was worried that it might have smudged all over the place but even after an hour of splashing around it stayed perfectly in place! Now that's what I call waterproof. It's not hard to take when you need to though, just use some eye make up remover and it comes off easily. The only possible downfalls that I've noticed are that it's not the best for tightlining (it's best as a pencil on the lids) and that sharpening this particular eyeliner pencil won't give you a really tapered end. But it's such a superb pencil all n all that nothing truely bothers me about it. Would definitely repurchase without a doubt!

I got this from sephora for about 17$
I was deciding between stila tiger eyes and UD eyeliners in brown. SO i tried all of them, including MUFE on my hands. All the liners were very creamy, and buildable colors. All of them also were smudge proof and had very good rating on MUA.
So I had all these liners on my hand and i brushes my finger over them. All but the MUFE Pearly Brown smudged.
Give my test a go yourself and you'll see the smudging

Oh.. I took it all off with sephora's makeup remover that they have on the shelves, and MUFE was the one that took a while to remove. The others came right off my hands.

This is a great color, close to Bobbi Brown Siena, a slightly olive-tinged plain brown--but the texture is just not working for me. I became a convert to pencils because of Urban Decay, which is unfailingly soft and easy to apply and wears like iron. I just can't get this one to apply without dragging, so it's hard to make a really smooth line. And even though I love the color, I find it tends to smudge. I wish it worked better for me!

This is truly waterproof. Doesn't smudge at all even when I yawn, sneeze, or fall asleep. I'm sure it will even stay put whilst swimming. I just wish this brown were darker. The color is a pretty shimmery medium brown. What I really need is a dark brown though. I also have to sharpen this pretty often because it goes blunt pretty fast, maybe because I use so much of it each time trying to get a darker line. I will buy this again though because in terms of not smudging, this is the best.

You can't cry it off. You can't swim it off. Mother nature can't even rain it off. The whole line of Aqua Eyes pencils is amazing, but this colour is my favourite because I can wear it all the time. I won't use any other liners but these ones!

Was my HG brown eyeliner pencil for a period of time until MAC comes with peralglides, then I got pulled away by Molasses. 2L is a warm brown, with a bit of bronze compared to Molasses.
The texture and staying power is very similar, both long-lasting on my oily lids and goes on smoothly, newbie proof :)

PERFECT PENCIL. Perfect dark brown with a HINT of shimmer. goes on like a dream---stays forever. amazing. Throw out everything else. seriously.

This is the perfect shimmery brown eyeliner. It's in the same family as MAC Teddy and UD Bourbon, only it goes on smoother and stays on longer. I mean it won't budge! If you're debating between Urban Decay 24/7 liners and these, I would definitely go with these.

After trying this eyeliner in Mat Black 0L, and loving it, I decided to try this color. The formula goes on incredibly smooth and even, it didn't pull or hurt like other "long-wearing" pencils, but this has the best staying power I’ve found! A great surprise.
The Pearly Brown shade looks like a metallic bronze in the pencil, but comes of as a dark chocolate brown which compliments my coloring very well (I have dark brown eyes and very dark brown hair). I don't even need powder to set it, this holds up in Texas humidity.
I will buy this again, and probably add some more colors. This is more expensive than I would like to spend, but since it does what it claims I'll bite the bullet and shell out the cash.