The pencil is smoother and creamier than the drugstore eyeliners I've tried and applies very well, subtly enhancing my lashline, but I've found that the liner migrates to my undereye circles by the end of a long night. I would say that this is decent for the cost, but would recommend trying some liquid or waterproof gel liner if you want something that stays for longer.
This pencil is very stiff. Maybe mine was too old but i prefer smooth eyeliner pencils that don't drag my lids as im applying it. This was a fail for me at least it was cheap
i really want to like this but its an OK pencil. i got this on a whim at ulta because my daughter had gotten into my makeup bag and broke my maybelline master drama liquid pencil. i don't like using gel liner for my waterline so i picked this up because i needed a new pencil. plus it was 50% off so i thought why not. it works well on my lash line but it literally wore off in like 15 minutes on my waterline. im glad i only got this for 77 cents but will never repurchase this
I got this in black/brown!! It is my Holy Grail eye product. Black looks a little harsh on me, although I have dark features, so black/brown is my perfect match. This also holds up pretty well, is creamy enough and easy to apply. LOVE!<3
i like this eyeliner it's not the best but i do have it in my everyday bag. i got it for a 4 dollars i believe. i don't remember where sorry. but for me being a broke college student 4 dollars is a lot for just one pencil of eyeliner. i buy the cheap LA colors eyeliner and it works just as good and it's a dollar.
Now, I do not like this product. Not at all, but when I was first starting out with makeup, the first store I went to had this product and I bought it. This smudges, not creamy, and it wears off easily. However, it is reasonably priced for the quality, I will say that.
I really like this. This isn't he most pigmented eyliner ever, but it's great for filling in my liquid eyeliner. It also is good on waterline. This takes work to show up, but I do like this. Got it for 3.50 at a local store.
Not a fan of pencil liners, but I just wanted to have one. It smudges very easily,too easy! I just use it for smokey eyes under my eyeshadow. I've wore it just lining my eyes but it left me looking like a raccoon in about 30mins.
Have been using this eyeliner for about a month now and I love it! In fact I just purchased another one today. You're getting a really creamy and pigmented eyeliner for just a few bucks and I can't express how much I love this eyeliner because its so creamy and easy to apply! I took off one lippie because it smudges a little within a few hours (I get teary easily).
I only bought this because Rimmel was out of their black eyeliner and this one had decent reviews. But after wearing it for several days, yesterday I especially noticed that after putting it on my lash line, there was what looked like smudged or runny marks on my bottom tear duct area. It looked like I had cried it off when I hadn't cried at all that day. It also doesn't go on as smoothly as I'd like. It will work for now until my Ulta stocks up their Rimmel black eyeliner again. Sigh.