This is my favorite e/l. It brings out my light brown eyes against my NC45 complexion. The longer I wear it during the day, the better it looks. It goes on smooth and it sets well. I can not rave more about this product and I would buy it again and again.

This metallic emerald green kohl is awesome on brown eyes, just as others have mentioned. It's really soft and goes on smoothly with good payoff on the color.

I use this Eye Kohl a lot as a base to my green eyeshadows. Since green can be tricky on Asian yellow-toned skin (it neutralizes), this Eye Kohl helps to intensify the green eye shadow. The color is very pigmented, but it's also buildable. I use lightly on my lid, blend it out, then put eyeshadow on top of it. I recently purchased the Photo Realism quad, and I use this Eye Kohl as a base. Beautiful. Really brings out my deep brown eyes.

Minted is absolutely one of my favorite liners to really accentuate and bring out my brown eyes. It's a very vivid emerald green that's bright without being obnoxious. Applies smoothly, lasts all day, and looks amazing with bronze eyeshadow to add a little contrast. One of first MAC eyeliners I ever purchased, and one of the few I've ever replaced. I adore this eyeliner!!

I am a total MAC fanatic so I'll admit, there are few MAC products I won't absolutely love. Minted is a great colour, I use it on my waterline and it somehow brings out the brown in my eyes and has great staying power (despite being a smudger myself!). The eyeliner itself has a great smooth texture and is too easy to apply. Love it!

this is one of my favorite makeup items that i own. like everyone has said, it is a beautiful emerald green color. now i just wish that i could find an eyeshadow in a similar shade!

A vivid grown green with subtle shimmer according to the MAC site. It seems more and more reviews trace back to one Kim Kardashian look or another and this one is no different. I saw a photo of Kim on Specktra with a beautiful greenish liner and someone had asked for recs. Another MAC fan had suggested Minted and so it began.

When I think of "grown green" I think of grass and this certainly is not a grass green shade IMO. It's more of a brighter slightly shimmery emerald shade. Beautiful on my hazel eyes, really brings them out, and will be lovely for a spring liner. No suprise why it is so striking on Kim, I think this would probably suit brown eyes the best but it definitely works for others as well.

This is a beautiful bright emerald green. This pencil goes on smoothly, and since it's a kohl, I can wear it on my waterline too. I wear this if I want to make my dark brown eyes stand out. For color reference, I am NC30. This is the brightest eye pencil I own, but I love it.

I love this Kohl! The color is gorgeous and my eyes turn GREEN when I wear this on my waterline. My eyes pop! This is the best kohl I've ever owned and I use it whenever. Can't live without it and have to buy again when this runs out!

my friend tried this out and i was immediately attracted to the gorgeous green color. i was devastated when i found out that is was an eye kohl and not a powerpoint. i kept thinking to myself that if the powerpoints smudge on me and "settle" on the outer corners of my eyes, then the eye kohls would surely be running down my face! against my better judgment and because of its beautiful shade, i decided to buy it. i was shocked when i tried it on because it hardly moves at all! i was impressed. it was waaay better than my powerpoints. it's a good thing that i did not listen to my initial instincts. this one's a keeper. i'm looking forward to trying other eye kohls with the hope that they too have the same staying power.


EDIT: Okay, so this doesn't settle on the outer corners of my eyes, but there are occasions when it does tend to smudge on my eyelids. Still love the color, though. Ü