Terrible.. This mascara dried out awfully,I got to wear it about 3 or 4 times and after that it was so dry there was no use for it.At first time use I was happy when it gave me very long and very volumised lashes.If only it would last normally.I tried to wash the mascara brush and thought if the problem could be fixed by that.No,it wouldn't help at all.Problem was the concistency of the mascara,it just dries so horrible way,what a sad thing for a woman who just wants to put on some mascara to get great lashes.Not with this stuff,a waste of money :-(

This mascara is nice if you like natural looking, clean lashes. I find it doesn't really lengthen or volumizes my lashes, which I look for in a mascara. It also doesn't hold a curl well. It does leave your lashes softer than other mascaras, but I don't mind hard lashes. Personally, I wouldn't repurchase or use it simply because I like fuller, longer looking lashes. I only use it on days I'm not going anywhere and if I want very minimal makeup. So definitely buy this if you go for natural lashes.

I bought this after I saw an ad in a magazine..say what?....Mega&plush?....right up my alley....not..I do NOT LIKE THIS sam I am...it clumps&made my lashes feel like they are gonna break off with only one coat...

It advertises being soft and non-clumpy but it made my eyelashes look clumpy and spidery but worked well on my bottom eyelashes.

It is a really soft and feathery mascara. It gives a really natural look. I like the formula, it's great and it doesn't smudge on me (which is a HUGE plus because everything smudge on me!!). On the other hand, it doesn't really hold a curl well and it's really hard to apply with the elbow wand. It's a really weird feeling and that the first time that I thought mascara shield was a must !

I wonder if it's really the formula that gives a really light look, or the fact that you have to use a really light hand to apply it without getting everywhere because of the elbow. I wish it could hold a curl better and that there was no elbow. I would purchase it again for sure if that was the case but it's not, so I'll definitively keep my hunt for the perfect mascara :(

Oh btw, I really like the packaging, it's super cute :)

This mascara is very soft, and does what it claims! Separates well and adds volume plus length. Only complaint is that it doesn't hold a curl well. Definitely repurchasing.

I love this mascara! I like how it doesn't clump and doesn't give you that spider lash effect. It does a great job of lengthening and making my lashes look thicker. My favorite thing about this mascara is how natural it keeps your lashes and how black it makes them! Definitely will be repurchasing this in the future!

I like the way it makes my lashes look but it flakes horribly after a weeks use. What a shame

This did anything BUT make my lashes plushy. Tried using with both loaded and almost dry brush, and all it did was make my lashes stick together and look spidery and clumpy. My clump crusher mascara does better at plush than this. I definitely will stick to the cover girl mascaras from now on.

I like the formula, this mascara makes my lashes full and maintains the curl all day long. The thing that I don't like, and for me it's a huge deal is the wand, I find it too flimsy and the bristles too all over the place, some are short and some are even longer than my lashes and when I try to work it in the roots I poke my lid.

Maybelline has very nice mascaras, it's a trial and error thing. Will try others to see how it goes.