This was my first liquid eyeliner and I am LOVING it. I bought it from Sasa when I was visiting HK after seeing Bubzbeauty recommend it and boy, it is fantastic for such a well-priced product (I forget the exact rice but under $20 for sure).

I bought both the brown and black one; the brown one isn't bad but the black one is pigmented so well! It is a thin feather tip application which took me a while to get used to but once i did, it goes on so smoothly and the best thing? It doesn't smudge! Even after a day of exercising and going around town, it didn't move an inch and give me owl eyes. I even accidentally touched it with my hand and it didn't even smudge.

It is definitely not water proof though to my surprise, it is considerably easy to remove with a few washes with warm water followed by my facial scrub.

Overall, the best starter liquid eyeliner I've ever bought, and the only one I will buy :)

I needed a new liquid eyeliner after my Lancome artliner dried up. I heard great reviews on this eyeliner and Saaammage says this is her HG eyeliner! Upon hearing these reviews, I just decided why not and bought it. I paid $18 for this on imomoko. This is more than I would pay for a liquid eyeliner, but it didn't concern me since I paid over $40 for the artliner. I didn't get the ultra kawaii old packaging with the pink exterior and black dots, but I got the new improved formula with Tsu-chan's new otona-kawaii packaging. I do find it kind of cute as it's pink and it has daisies that circumferences the eyeliner, but I don't find it as cute as the old packaging. The tip of the eyeliner is ULTRA fine and it is damn precise. If you have shaky hands, then you should rest your arms or whatever because this eyeliner will have no issue in showing every single mistake. I don't mind this as I can build the eyeliner to desired thickness. The eyeliner is extremely black and dries fast which I love, unlike the crap artliner that takes a while to dry. I have cried in this eyeliner and of course I have walked in the rain with it on. It doesn't even budge. Quite surprising! I'm pretty sure it does come off with warm water, as I've tested it on my hand but I always take off my eye makeup with either an eye makeup remover or with the MAC cleanse off oil. In total, I do like this eyeliner but the only drawback it has is that sometimes it doesn't come out pigmented and black. It'll come off as sheer and grayish in which I have to shake the pen itself to fix it, but I guess I can possibly deal with the inconsistency.

Despite being more expensive than I'd like it to be, this is hands down the best liquid eyeliner I have ever used. For some reason, eyeliner really likes to smudge on my eyelids. I have tried looking for an eyeliner that is decently pigmented for a long time, and because I'm a fan of Tsubasa Masuwaka, I decided to pick this up. The pigmentation of this liquid eyeliner is very dense, and the brush allows absolutely control over the thickness of the line desired. It can be easily taken off by warm water (although I still use eye make up remover afterwards just to make sure everything is off), yet it doesn't even budge after I stand in the rain or cry. I have yet to find a better liquid eyeliner than the Dolly Wink liquid eyeliner.

This eyeliner is very black and doesn't smudge at all. But my hands are not that steady and the tip is on the soft side so I don't have as much control as I would like.

I bought this after the rave reviews on MUA, got it off eBay for about NZD$22. I am very disappointed in this product. I bought it because my hand isn't that steady and it was quite hard to make a thin line with my previous liquid eyeliner. The problem I am finding with this is that although it has a fine tip, the product runs into the creases of my eye, so in turn I have to go back over it and it makes the line thicker anyway! It seems quite watery as well and no easier than my original Australis eyeliner, which I still have and will stick to and try and get better at, because it is a MUCH cheaper product that lasts ten times longer and gives a darker black. Not impressed at all.

best eye liner ive ever tried!
ppl with oily lids, this is the one to get! its comparable but BETTER than the physicians formula liquid liner and the k-palette 24 hour liner

physicians formula is what i use when i run out of this one, its slightly more liquidy and flakes a bit after 4-5 hours or wear

k-palette smudges a bit more

this one seems to work best on my oily lids, it has a super thin and firm brush that makes application super easy, its very black, it stays in place all day and is also easy to remove with some water or just a bit of makeup remover if u want it to come off even easier.

Super goooooooooooooooooooooooood!

The best of the best. Tsubasa is a Japanese model who came out with her own line of cosmetics. The Koji Dollywink is even better than the K-Palette 24hr. liner in my opinion because it is more pigmented. I live in SoCal where it is super hot and this did not budge even with my oily lids. I also took this with me to Taiwan where it is super humid, and still this did not budge. Super fine tip that easily gives you the perfect thin line or flick, however it is also very easy to create a medium thick line with. For everyday I choose this over my BB gel liner because it is so quick and easy and really shortens my routine, especially when I'm in a rush for school. Sets immediately and does not smudge. Not waterproof, but hold up well if you have watery eyes and rub your eyes a lot. HG and definte repurchase. Purchased this for around $12 while I was in Taiwan

OMG, this eyeliner is the best smudge-proof eyeliner ever! I have really OILY lids..and ive tried hundreds of eyeliners from- Drugstore brands (loreal, maybelline, etc.) to High Ends (MAC, Lancome, Bobbi Brown) and every single one of em seems to always fail on me. The one that lasted the longest was the Bobbi Brown one, but it STILL smudge and creased on my eye even with a PRIMER. This is my first time purchasing an eyeliner from out of this country, and its the ONLY eyeliner that stays on for more than 8+ hours for me. I would highly recommend this product.

Love this eyeliner! I bought it in black from ebay for £8.29. I had never used this kind of eyeliner but the fine tip makes it super easy to control and good for filling in lashline without that burning feeling. I'm not sure if it's completely waterproof but it doesn't smudge! The packaging to really cute aswell.