Honestly not too shabby for a $1 mascara! I bought this on a whim b/c I have this obsession with mascaras and I have to put one in my basket every time I'm at a Target (sigh).

PROS:
CHEAP!
Formula is not too wet/not too dry
Cute/sleek packaging
No flakes
Brush is perfect size for my small eyes
Better at volumizing than lengthening
Easy to remove

CONS:
Not waterproof
Does NOT hold a curl
Not really defining or lengthening
Clumpy
Too much product on the brush

I will not rebuy this product:(
Reasons why I will not rebuy this product:

1) It clumps REAL BAD :0

2) The aplicator is terrible

3) Drys in bottle:(

I got this in the holiday season at gordmans

I love E.L.F it is very nice but this product sucks:''''''(

Crappiest mascara I`ve ever tried :( It did not dry! When I touched my eyelashes several hours after applying, they were sticky and clung together. Wow.

I bought this mascara in a holiday set for $3, which came with black, dark brown, and clear mascara. So it's incredibly cheap! And though it is not waterproof, it does not smudge and is easy to take off. It does thicken and lengthen my lashes, though not as much as I usually prefer. I like to use these on days when I want a more natural look, and for that, they do their job well!

The only major problem I have with these is the packaging. It's almost like there is just way too much product crammed in the tubes, so it tends to glob out. If you don't wipe the tip of the wand with the tissue, it can be quite messy. I don't like how it basically forces you to waste product. However, once you use the tube up halfway, the problem is basically gone.

I most likely will repurchase, especially if they are sold individually. I love the clear mascara the most for keeping brows in place.

Worst crap I have ever bought, the low price doesn't smooth over how horrible this mascara is. I bought both black and brown when I last ordered from elf and both of them have been such a let down!
The formula is too dry and no matter how much I use it almost doesn't show up on my lashes at all..! Sure I have wuite black lashes to begin with but I have never ever tried a mascara that does so little for my lashes.
Cant recommend to anyone, I have thrown both away. Will NEVER buy again.

It really didn't do anything for my lashes, they were just black. Even when I curled them before applying, it barely did anything. It was much better for my bottom lashes, but still not that good.

This is the worst mascara ive EVER tried. Its seems like it dried out immediately. The wand is ridiculous. So cheap and ugly. The formula is clumpy and thick. I couldnt coat my lashes, the mascara was so thick that it didnt come off the wand.
It was cheap, but still, waste of money.

Money is getting a little tight, so came to Makeup Alley for some help and I totally found it! This mascara is great!!! A little bit of Flakey-ness at the end of night, but at the END. Be aware though that is not the same as the lengthening and volumizing, make sure that you're getting the triple pack. Thank you makeup alley!!!!! And last but ,especially not least $3.00!!!!!!!!! I will be buying again and again!

Quite happy with this product - its affordable (hello $10 for a mascara and two eyeliners!) and it WORKS! I love how its pigmented, it lengthens and it holds my lashes!

Got this for $3 at Target... I was buying expensive mascara for years...WAY WAY too long. I read the reviews and LOVE this. I will never again spend more then a few dollars on mascara again. The consistency is perfect...not clumpy...very buildable. Will absolutely buy again!!