I love this eyeliner. It really does remind me of ink. This does not smudge and dries quickly. It doesn't run onto my eyelashes. If you want a dramatic look you most shake well or else you'll only get a faint line. I will defiantly repurchase.

I just got this in a swap in Brown and I love it! I've been using it everyday. I have never used brown liner but its really pretty and subtle. I like this pen because its fool proof. You can def pull of a good wing-eyed look easier than with a liquid or gel liner at least for me. The pigment is not super dark brown but I like that. Looks naturally pretty but enough to bring out your eyes. Try it & if you dont like it, I will swap for it :) continued >>

*BEFORE*
Alright I have to say that before buying this eyeliner on sale at Sally's, I'd tried to apply eyeliner once, and it was my moms with the brush applicator. Long story short, I really messed up with the application and swore I'd never use liquid again.
Hahaha well here I am using it, and I love it! It took about a week of using it at home when I wasn't at school, but I got it down. If I want a thin line, I only use the tip. But if I want thick Cleopatra liner, turn it on its side and voila!
Best tip ever! It's felt, super comfortable, and it doesn't spread all over the place. Just a lil bit of liner and you're ready to go.
Definitely buying this again! =)

*AFTER*
OK I came back to edit my review for this one because when I reviewed the first time, it was the day after using it. But I noticed that the tips wouldn't release any liner, they'd dry up even if I did shake them up, and would give then not give me liner. I've decided to give up on Palladio, sticking to Covergirl, Maybelline, and L'Oreal cosmetics from now on.

I LOVE THIS EYELINER!!!! this is my favorite eyeliner... well, at least for right now. I like how they design it to have a pen tip, but unlike of the other pen tip eyeliner this one doesn't dry out. I have the purple and black color, they both work wonders...

CONS:
since its labeled ink, (if its a pen its dark first then faded if out of ink) as i line my eyes its like fade black then i line again.
PROS:
love love the tip, you can line from the thinnest to thickest line. it stays all day. i can apply it my lower lash line without making it look harsh/too heavy for the area.

Awesome, awesome, awesome!! It's so hard to find an eye marker that actually works. You can get such a precise line with this marker, but the best part is that it actually produces a dark liquid line that you don't even have to go over a second time! And it lasts all day. Can't beat it. Love it. Will repurchase again and again and again.

I bought this product in eggplant and I am really loving it! its a beautiful purplely brown! its demure and subtle and you can tell that its purple but its not a true bright pigment. I love bright purples but there are days when i just want to keep it low key. I'm an eyeliner freak and I feel naked without it! this is a great color because I feel like im wearing my usual heavy liner but it looks so nice! This is a work appropriate color for sure and goes really well with very neutral colors. The color is almost lavender or lilac hued, do not expect to be able to wear this with non-neutral shadows. I love the way this applies, its literally the fastest eyeliner for me to put on! super great plus! I really want to try the black!

I absolutely love this eye liner! It goes on with one swipe and stays on all day! It's the perfect size as well. It's small enough that you can get a nice hold on it. * Two thumbs up! *

I really like this Eye Liner. Ease of use never have had a steady hand at liquid liner. I purchased the black and then went back and purchase SMOKY which is a greyish hue.It stays put after it dries. Will be going back for the other colors. I would like for it to be alittle slimer for applying ease on the hand. The felt end is a breeze to apply to the eye with or without false lashes.

This eyeliner is great! It sticks like superglue. The color payoff is excellent. I like the selection of colors available and the ease of application. The felt tip applicator makes application extremely easy. I can apply this with either my left or right hand without any problem. I HATE HATE HATE how small the tube is. This really should be larger. . It dries really fast so be prepared to start over if you make a mistake. I haven't experienced any type of irritation (which is a plus). EDIT: 10-19-11 Aside from the tube be entirely too small for the price, I notice obstruction to my vision whenever I use this. There's always a "haze" or something and I constantly find myself trying to remove something from my eye....but nothing is there. I went to work and wash my face and removed the eyeliner and the "haze" was gone within 30 minutes. I will not be using this product again.