I have the SMOKEY edition.
Good pigmentation.
Doesn't flake.
Wears well.
Pretty colours.
Recommended.

I have brown eyes with a touch of hazel and found that this hazel palette works the best for my eyes. In the packaging, some of the colors actually bleed into the others, making them slightly unusable. There is also a slight tendency for creasing, but don't get me wrong, the positive definitely outweighs any negatives of this product and will definitely buy again.

I have brown eyes and love this palate! Great colors, but definitely shimmery! Wonderful for summer, but sometimes feels like a little much for work. I love it for travel, because all your colors are in one place. They blend well and are fun to play around with.

Overall I think this is a good palette. Several colors, although they are all in the same color families. The packaging is nice, imo. I honestly think PF products are overpriced, but I'm sure I got this on sale.

9 colors in 3 combinations. Practical and versatile. You can mix them though.
Simple and compact package. 1 sponge with no mirror. You'd better use other brushes for better blending.
A little chalky. Lasts ok.
Nice shimmer. You can wear it to work.

I like these just fine – a good purchase. Perfect as an all-in-one for weekend travel or overnights. Some of the colours are definitely more shimmery than others - and I personally tend to avoid them except to highlight. But you get a great range of complimentary colours to play with. The darker colours can be used dry as a liner, which looks very nice. These colours do enhance and compliment my hazel eyes. Like it! Price I thought was a little on the expensive side, though I did get them on sale, and the packaging is a little frustrating - sometimes it's hard to instinctively know which end to open (they open on the long side) - and I've struggled in the mornings when I'm totally uncoordinated to try and get the sucker open. These will last a long time, and I probably won't buy again just because I'm sure by the time I'm done with it, new products will be available.

I have brown eyes, but love love love wearing all of these colors. Brown eyes are the most versatile color to work with other colors and the different hues of pinks and smoky brown purples made my eyes pop! The staying power of these shadows is fantastic, and if I foil (wet my brush) before application, the effect is glamorous! The container lasts forever, but will be quickly used because the colors are just SOO pretty! My only gripe is that the eye shadows tend to break easily and the colors can get dirty because theres nothing to separate from one another .. like the white can get messy by the pinks and the brown purple gets into the pink.. but it's not a big deal as long as you're careful it's not something to carry around in the bottom of your purse -- you have to put it somewhere safe..

I love the colors. I wear the two darkest colors everyday. It last all day. They were going on clearance the other day at Wal-greens so I went and bought more. I even get compliments on my eyes and they ask what color I am wearing.

I like all the colors, its a good buy because its 9 colors for 9 bucks that all work with hazel eyes. With 3 premade combos. I haven't tried it wet yet, but it looks good dry. I like the applicator that comes with. Will rebuy!

*This can be found at drugstores like Target, Walgreens, RiteAid...etc. But I'm not sure if it's been discontinued or not.

-Pros:
Pigmented
Blends well
Colors work well with each other
Great price

-Cons:
Very shimmery/frosty
Needs primer or it will crease