I love this! I use the aqua black as a "gel/cream" liner and this works great for that purpose, I have also used it as an eyeshadow base for a dark smoky eye and as an eyeshadow on its own ... WOW! it works so well as all of these, it really is an "all in one" type of product. It doesn't budge at all! and is also super pigmented and really smooth, glides on like a dream. I have been a long time user and lover of Bobbi Brown gel liner in Black ink but I think this has definitely become my new must have gel liner!.. I have only been using this for 3 weeks so may edit my review based on how long it lasts in the pot before it starts to dry up.. lets see! but I say go and pick it up you won't be disappointed :)

I wanted to love this product, but for some reason I find it to be a very dry formula. While it is very black and it stays well on my lash and waterline I don't find that it is that easy to create a fluid line. I much prefer a creamier gel liner. Would not buy again.

This was quite rubbish on me. I always wear an eye primer (Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance) and although I've always had trouble with gel/cream liners giving me raccoon eyes, this one was the worst.

Last time I used it, I got raccoon eyes in less than an hour, before I even left the house. This was really disappointing because I quite liked their Aqua Liners, so I thought this would be good for me too. continued >>

This is best use for dark black liner for your waterline. Does not smudge or fade. A Sephora associate recommended this product to me. It is kind of pricey for my taste. Around $22, I think.. But well worth it! It stays on pretty long. I even took a nap with it on, even though I probably shouldnt have.. But it still looked like I just applied it on. It didn't even fade away! I absolutely love this product!! It's nice and creamy and very dark black. Will repurchase this again...

OMG! Isn't this the best product? I can't get over the Make Up For Ever range especially since it hit my favourite store Fresh! :-D

So I went and got heaps and probably too much but my goodness this is probably the best product with exception of the HD Foundation (another review coming there!).

It stays on beautifully, looks great and doesn't smudge, budge or move anywhere.

I have received so many compliments about this product its crazy!

I'd definitely recommend this product and most of my friends are already busily ordering one for themselves ;-)

Let me premise that I have very oily lids that I have to use 2 primers (UPP and MAC paint pot) and I've loved Blacktrack forever but it creased like crazy, even with black eyeshadow on top and it doesn't help that I have very hooded asian eyes. I bought this to try out and although it's not 100% waterproof it's the best I've tried so far. It dries fairy quickly but I like that. It is a charcoal black and not an intense black so I'll sometimes layer MAC Feline underneath to make it more intense. This last really well through my P90X workouts and sometimes overnight when I'm too lazy to wash my makeup off but removes pretty easily. This is my HG until something better comes along.

This stuff is actuually BOMB. It completely stays on all day at school, through to the evening for my late two hour soccer games. Friggin amazing, and its not like the pot is gonna be running out anytime soon, will last for a very long time. The pigmentation ir\s seriously black, no questions asked. It is pure, dark, charcoal black that lasts. you need to practice applying it a couple of time to get the hang of it but is relatively easy to work with

I love this stuff! It's super black and very creamy. I use this on the lower lash line and upper lash line and it applies very smoothly. It stays put all day. I do use a primer underneath.

I love this eyeliner it is absolutely amazing, I have repurchased this product 3 times. Which is a lot for me, as I tend to have a lot of black liner at any point in time. This product is extremely black, with no apparent undertone, even if it is applied lightly. I apply it with an thin angled brush on my tightline, waterline and upper lashline and it does not move from any of them. I can wear this eyeliner on my waterline all the way through a 12 hour day without touch ups on my waterline. This product is a must have for anyone looking for a very black, long wearing eyeliner. The only downside is that it was about 25 dollars Canadian...but for such an amazing product it is well worth it!

Wow, this product is amazing. I was really disappointed with MUFE's Aqua Eyeliner pencil, it is not as great as they make it out to be, you have to buy their sharpener, etc. But, this is an entirely different product. Much better than a pencil or liquid liner, and stays all day. I apply it with an slanted eyeliner brush and then use a smudge brush to smudge it. The line is not too "hard" and not too "soft" it is juuussst right...My new favorite eyemakeup. I guess I'll have to forgive MUFE for their crappy pencil liner and try some of their other cream formulations.