I just got this and figured I'd try it for $1. I can't even use it because it's so thick and dry, right out of the package. Save your money and get something better!

This mascara was so bad, when I had opened it up (note:got it in brown) I started laughing. Usually when you get something bad, you get upset about it but when I opened it up I kinda expected it... I mean what the hell was I thinkin getting a 1$ mascara? lol Not even worth the dollar though. It was clumpy like gunk and it was dry haha worst thing ever.

I recently discovered e.l.f. so I wanted to try the mascara. I've been using Maybelline mascara forever but I wanted to try something else. The e.l.f. mascara may be cheap but that doesn't make it worth buying again! It is very clumpy (it looks like I have tarantulas for eyelashes!) and doesn't lengthen at all. I love all of the other e.l.f. products but the mascara really misses the mark! The only way I could recommend this is if you are buying for a little girl to play makeup with. Other than that, it's a no-no for me!

I really dislike this mascara.

The mascara is dry (although that might be the fault of the packaging/how long it was in the warehouse before I purchased it) and it comes with very little product.

Both the regular and the waterproof sides apply the same (disappointingly) and the formulation can get so thick that the brush is difficult to take out and it end up coming out of the packaging that holds both sides together.

Overall, a disappointing product that I'm glad was only $1 and not a penny more!

I have read the other reviews on this and see that mostly everyone was extremely disappointed. I bought it only because it was $1, and figured that it could either be a loss or a gain. After trying it out, I was not completely satisfied, nor completely disappointed. it does come out clumpy on the wand, so you have to wipe off the excess before applying, and it doesn't lengthen my eyelashes at all, although it does make them appear thicker (maybe just because it's a little clumpy.) Overall though, it's not a horrible product but I probably wouldn't purchase it again.

This is an okay mascara. I bought it because it was just a dollar, and I thought the waterproof/non-waterproof duo was a good idea. It's not too clumpy, but not really lengthening or volumizing. I'll use it up on days just running around doing errands and whatnot, but I will not repurchase.

I'm actually impressed with this dirt cheap mascara. I bought it for travel and it's absolutely perfect for that purpose! The tube is small and slim and will fit anywhere. I love the fact that you get a regular and wp version in one tube. Not sure if the other reviewers got a bad batch but my formula was nice and wet. The actual performance of this mascara is okay. It gives good separation and length but little volume. After two layers, I was satisfied with the results and it didn't way down my curl. The mascara will last on a hot and humid day without smudging or fading. Also, I experienced no flaking with this. For travel, this is a great purchase! I think this mascara outperfoms some of the well known ones from L'Oreal, Revlon and Maybelline.

This product is really dirt cheap, it costs $1 at Target where I got it. I really liked how well it worked on my eyelashes but overtime the product got dry really fast. I had it for about a couple of months and the brush seemed to not glide as easily like the beginning. It dried super fast. Before I bought this mascara I bought the Covergirl lashblast volume which did not dry out as fast as this mascara and I am still using it. This product works really well but let me just say its not worth the buy if it will only last you a couple months where a more pricier mascara can last you several months.

This must be a joke. I have NEVER been subjected to a mascara that was completely dry right out of the package. That includes both ends. What kind of company would sell a product that you couldn't even use. I guess you get what you pay for. NEVER AGAIN will I buy this mascara. It went directly into the trash because I couldn't use it even one time!!!

This is the first Elf mascara I tried and I was very surprised & impressed on how it made my lashes look so much better, compare to using higher end mascaras. I also purchased their mineral mascara and was more impressed! In my opinion, Elf is very competitive when it comes to mascaras at a fraction of a cost. So far, I haven't purchased a dried out batch from them. I love how this mascara glides on smoothly and lengthens my lashes. Great product and I'm probably not going back to pricier drugstore mascaras. continued >>