I asked the MAC artist for their darkest brown liner for a smokey bronze look and she recommended Stuborn Brown. The color is pretty, but the color wasn't as dark on the eye as it looked when swatched on the hand. It also didn't go on smooth and tugged on my eyelid. I will be trying MAC Photogravure next as it is described as a soft black with brown.
Great eyepencil easy to use and not hard to apply, doesnt drag and you dont have to warm it up, staying power is 4-5 hrs not the best but definetly looks natural towards the end of the day.
This is "the" basic brown to have. It's easy and creamy to apply and stays put till you choose to take it off. Love it.
I got this pencil in a swap, and I was really surprised by it. It's so soft, and the color is so beautifull (a very dark tone of brown). It's very easy to use and to smudge. It's impossible for me to make a defined line with it, but my intention, when I use this liner, is to make a thicker line that I can smudge, as if i used wet eyeshadow. I doesn't last all day, but I don't care, because I don't expect any pencil liner to last long, anyway. I want to try other colors of this range!
I have a serious problem with transfer under my eyes when it comes to eyeliner. I luv UD 24/7 but they transfer. This eyeliner was recommended by MUA at Mac and I luv it. It stays put all day and no more transfer. The only thing is if you blend to smoke out you must do it fast as it sets quick but it is awesome and cheaper then UD. Buy it you will not regret!!!
I went to MAC looking for the perfect chocolate brown eyeliner and I found it! This is a highly pigmented eyeliner, which stays on my waterline all day! A staple in my makeup bag, will repurchase :)
FAV BROWN EYELINER. stays all day. gorgeous brown. sharpens amazing. overall-I LOVE THIS. :D
This is a good color eyeliner. Nothing special about the color but the staying power is very good. I was looking for something to replace Teddy liner.
HG for brown liner. I have oily skin and this last an entire work day without smudging or running. It makes my light brown eyes pop! It looks very natural and goes on very easy. I look they way it looks on and under my waterline. This with Plush Lash in brownette is the perfect combination.
Good points to note is that one or two strokes is enough to get the colour on. It won't smudge or transfer (don't bother smudging it, doesn't really smudge nicely). Its a basic brown in my opinion. I'd like it to be darker for intensity. It goes well with Embark and Bronze eyeshadow. I only wore this on my lower lash waterline. Never on the upper lid. I have an aversion to putting liner on the upper lid. It has to be goof proof or I have to be in the mood for precision. I found that it didnt last long. I used Teddy more often and it lasted longer but I had to keep sharpening Stubborn Brown to get it nice and pointy for application needs. Um, what else can I say. Half of the liner went away in just sharpening alone... not worth it. NOW i use Dior Cryon Eyeliner in Deep Brown. Which is amazing in application, more rich and dark and intense and I don't have to sharpen it all the time.