I got this wanting to try out Sephora eyeliner without spending too much. I did not like it. It stayed on forever, which was good for going out, but when I tried to take it off I had difficulties. It's also a bit bigger than a standard eyeliner pencil, so you have to buy their special sharpener to sharpen it, which is basically just a ploy to get more money out of you. The price is cheap for Sephora, but the quality sucks. I will not be buying this again.
Overall, this is a great buy. It has great pigmentation, and lasts all day. My only complaint is that it is a little hard to apply; if it were just a bit creamier, my application of this liner would be a lot better. However, I would still buy this.
These little liners are so cute! I have this in Black, Blue, White, and Grey and they are highly pigmented. I can really do a smoky eye with this because its creamy and its easy to smudge. I use the White one for my tear duct, the inner corners of my eye (not in the inside but it the outside like on my eyelid, be careful while doing this!) for a highlight. The only issue I have with these is that it doesn't fit sharpeners, not even sephora sharpeners! I bought the sharpener for 2 bucks and it didn't work buuut the sharpener from Clinique that comes with the eye liner is a perfect fit!
I like the idea of a small eyeliner for such a great price, but this one didn't deliver. The texture is super creamy, which I like and it goes on nicely, but good luck getting it to stay that way!
I have mixed feelings about this product, I had purchased it in nuage after seeing how amazing it looked swatched and I got silver green in a birthday gift for free along with aspen summit eyeshadow. I must say I cannot get any of nuage on my waterline and in order for any colour payoff I have to swipe it many times and tug on my eyes a lot, which since the crayon is so small I'm not getting the bang for my buck I wanted with getting what I thought would be a $5 pencil convenient for in my purse. What I liked about it is that it's a nice shimmery colour for the lid but I find I don't use it much. I like the silvery green and shows up pretty well in my lashlines but not in my waterlines without tugging, it does look very good with the aspen summit eyeshadow however, but I do need to swipe the pencil a few times also. Overall, I won't be repurchasing.
I like this product because even though it's a small amount, it's only $5. It's something small for to go and it's easy to glide on. Some of the colors are more pigmented than others and they are also easy to blend as eyeshadows.
I got this in Pearl Beige. The color in the stick is very pretty, but it doesn't show up all that well. The product doesn't have much staying power. Overall, I would not buy this again.
Purchased the nano eyeliner in pure white for the purpose of using it on my water line. The price was right and from what I have seen, most of the nano eyeliners have a decent ingredients list. This irritated my eyes too much to be used on my water line and the staying power was poor.
I really like this eyeliner (mine is in Coffee). It has a nice warm brown-black color and I like it a lot. No skipping or breaking, and the lines have pretty good staying power. It's become a staple.
The only reason I didn't give 5 lippies is that this is a real pain to sharpen. For some reason these are a really really tight fit in the sharpener and you can just barely turn the pencil. I think that you really need to buy the Sephora sharpener if you are going to pick one of these up. But at least the color I had worked great, I highly recommend it.
I've tried two colors (a silvery green and a bright blue) and I'm currently on my third black pencil. They're definitely a good staple, nothing special but quite cheap, fairly pigmented and pretty good quality.