Highly pigmented however smudges terribly on my oily eyelids and even transfers down to my lower lash line. I did not have a problem with the product drying up because I always stored it upside down. The consistency is nice and creamy and sets to a matte finish. Unfortunately, it just isn't for me.
I've been using this product for 3 years and I absolutely LOOVVEE it.
It's definitely a better/more affordable alternative to the MAC fluidline and the Bobbi Brown Gel liner.
Its gel formula is super smooth on my eyes and doesn't fade/smudge over time even with my sometimes oily lids. The brush it comes from is also great for anything from a thin line to a dramatic cat eye.
Overall, an amazing drug store eyeliner.
nice gel eyeliner, one of the best you'll find in drugstore. My only complaint is that it can dry up after a few months which is a shame
About me: NW13 (neutral-cool toned, very fair), blue eyes, Color season is True Summer, Baumann Skin Type is OSPW.
The color in the pot is lighter and warmer than what actually goes on the lid: a dark, cool toned brown. Similar to Essence’s London Baby, a LE dark taupe gel liner that many covet. However, in my opinion, while it is just as dark as London Baby, it looks lighter or less dramatic because it’s not as pigmented. Additionally, I think this has less of a reddish tone found in the taupe of London Baby.
The views on how pigmented this product is tend to vary. Some PPP complained that this brown is too harsh for day wear. I think it’s confusing because while the actual color is dark, the pigmentation is lighter than it could be. To call this a “soft dark brown” would be most accurate. I have worn it for day wear and I’m NW13. And while the color is decently buildable, I wouldn’t expect this to stand out in low lighting though. It’s for medium impact.
PACKAGING / BRUSH:
Price is $5-8, I tend to find these for closer to $10. Expensive for drugstore, but a fraction of what you’d pay for a medium or high end liner, of which it’s performance compares. Although you get more product with a MAC liner.
Many stated they didn’t purchase the product expecting to use the brush, but that it was a decent brush that allows for versatility, both thin and thick lines. Don’t expect this brush to last you forever, but at least the life span of the product (until you get a new brush!)
There is debate on whether this is creamier than medium to high end liners, or not. Some said MAC Fluidline’s gel was dryer in formula. Smoother than Bobbi Brown’s gel liner. Regardless of how it compares to high end liners, this is definitely easy to apply and goes on very smooth, even after a year of wear. For those that think this is dry, I did hear the brown formula is dryer than the black formula.
Not many complained of it drying too fast, as some gel liners, and especially liquid liners do. It seems very forgiving in application, meaning you can wipe off any that you over-applied. Some did say that it took longer than usual to dry, but maybe this is when the container is brand new. I have not had those issues with mine, and it is over two years old.
I did not have any issues with smudging or transferring to my upper lid. I don’t have those issues with any of the gel liners I’ve tried, just with very soft pencils like MAC’s Eye Kohl. Applying eye shadow on top of the liner to “set” it might eliminate this problem for others, but that’s an “extra step,” and I try to avoid those as much as possible with HG products, unless they are LE or so unique I can put up with the extra legwork involved to make them suitable for every day wear.
Many commented that this lasts all day. I got about 6-12 hours. About the same that I get from other gel liners, using NYX HD eye shadow primer underneath. One review suggested using this product in conjunction with an eye shadow primer for longest results. I would imagine that most people use a primer underneath their shadows, and thus would automatically be using a primer underneath. So while this is technically an “extra step,” in practice it probably won’t be.
Is it waterproof? Equal votes yes and no. Not sure if I would recommend this as HG for your waterline. Yes, you can get it to stay after a few swipes, but it’s not dramatic, and at least for me, it didn’t last all day on my waterline like it did my lids. Another review suggested applying pencil liner underneath and this liner on top for maximum lasting capacity. This sounds like maybe more trouble than the product is worth.
For removal, some protested having to use a secondary eye make up remover to get it off. However, I always remove my make up using a two or three step process: massage an oil into my make up to loosen it, cleanse using liquid cleanser and water or a make up remover wipe, and tone. Otherwise, my skin gets easily clogged. On the plus side, this seems to be non-irritating. Some said MAC’s Fluidline irritated their eyes more.
This is a good drug store product. It won’t dry out before you use it up, and the little brush that comes with it is a bonus. I don’t think you will find this gel liner to be any more spectacular than the mid- and high-end range products, especially in terms of vibrancy of color or how long it lasts, but it’s not a waste of money, as many drug store products are.
it's been my second bottle so far. best for night out occasion and also for clubbing cause it's sweatproof.
easy to apply and give the best result for cat eyes.
I'm still looking for a better eyeliner, but this does the job. It goes on nice and smoothly. Unfortunately I usually have to pat it with a cotton ball after because I find there's a lot of excess liner that always ends up on my eyelid. The brush it comes with kinda sucks, so I suggest buying a better a brush along with it.
Don't even think about it for tightlining or waterlining. I tried every suitable brush I had ( the one provided is annoyingly useless in this case) Way too much effort because it is not pigmented. It's not in any way even a poor relation to Essence gel liners. It has a thinner consistency then their Color Tattoos, but I tried to make it do something for me since it's a nice true mid brown and played with it as a crease color. Not bad, it spreads around easily. There, I thought! I repurposed it! Not! It just looks dirty after a short while and shmeers like crazy even with primed eyes.
This was my first eyeliner purchase, and I am very pleased with this product! I found the gel really easy to apply, even though I had no idea what I was doing. The only time this has ever given me raccoon eyes is once after a day of walking downtown in the summer, so I'm forgiving it for that one. It stays put for me, and the brush itself is amazing!!! It allows you to put as much or as little as you like. The only reason I don't wear this more often is it is very dark, too dark for my ppp skin. I didn't realize the brown was as dark as it is, but I still wear it out at night! Overall a great liner, and one that is great for beginners to try!
This was a mess for me. I put it on with high hopes in the morning, went out for 2 hours and came back with a huge black mess around my eyes. Never used it again. This seriously does not work in warm weather. Maybe you'll have better luck in cold weather but why take the risk? Just get a better eyeliner.
I'm gonna try wearing it smudged next. Can't throw away a whole pot of eyeliner right. Hopefully the less you wear the less damage it can do...
awesome product, looks like liquid without the mess. can wear it alone or with a pencil liner (for smudging) this has become a must for me