The best. I was searching for an eyeliner that can stay for a day without retouching it. It stays same after all day! I would definitely repurchase after finishing the first bottle.
The color is very black, the texture is super creamy, stays put for a long time, only down side is that it smudges just a tiny bit on my lower lash line.
This gel is way cool! I finally found something that truly stays on all day. I work 10 hour shifts and I am gone 12 hours per day. I come home at night and violà....it is all still there, the same intense as when I first put it on. I do not have oily skin around my eyes, so anyone who feels the liner doesn't stay on all day, may have a bit of oily skin????? Try putting on a base of powder prior. I will definitely buy this product again and will now be tempted to try out different shades too.
I like this gel liner. It is a little expensive (it's $15.00 USD, but I got it for $16.17 after TAX) but I shouldn't complain since it's not a drug store product. All drug store gel liners always smudge on me. But this gel liner doesn't smudge at all! The only problem for me is that it fades throughout the day. Not a lot, but just a tad bit. Not very noticeable, but I'd like the full pigmentation to stay. It also slightly transfers from the top of my eyelid to the bottom, making me look tired. This slightly comes off when you curl your lashes. And if you don't pack the product on your brush, it isn't opaque. Otherwise, you'll find yourself dipping your brush back into the jar fairly often. I probably won't be repurchasing though since I think the Essence gel eyeliner is much better. Stays put longer than this one and doesn't move. If the Essence one ever discontinues, I would go back to this one, definitely.
This is the best of a bad bunch. If you’re in the market for a black gel liner I would say this is the best out there. Unfortunately for me these products tend to smudge like crazy.
TIP: Apply black eye shadow over the top for quick drying and to stop smudging.
I use this product when I have some extra time on my hands as the application process takes a while.
This product on its own smudges by the middle of the day. If you apply a black eye shadow over the top I find the last power is much better. This product appears quiet pigmented in the pot however takes a few coats to build up. Nothing to complain about, when it builds up it is a lovely intense black.
Still on the hunt for a waterproof gel liner that doesn’t smudge but will use this until I can find something better!
Blacktrack left a lot to be desired in my experience. It's not black enough, and is almost dark gray. That forces me to go back over the first stroke, and when I do the second stroke it takes off the first even when I let the first dry before applying again. I know it's not because of the brush I used because I do have other gel liners and they go on very pigmented with the same brush. Wear time was just average and it's not anything to write home about at all. It started running/smudging around hour 5. I need my liners to last longer than that.
I used this with MAC's 266 angled brush. Worked very well. Always got perfect lines and wings. Smooth (but not as smooth as bobbi brown) black and pigmented. Never smudged and I'm anal about transferring products! Best liner I have ever used on my lid. Can't say much for water lines though. Only problem, it dried out fairly quick (compared to other gel liners) but only because I used it on the weekends. If you used this every day or close to it then this is perfect! A seriously recommended product! Oh and make sure you close the lid tighly!
True black liner that is long wearing. Applies easily with a liner brush. Works in the waterline. The packaging works well and prevents the product from drying out.
This has been my only eyeliner for years and years. A pot of it lasts me quite a few months, and the wear is great.
The best in the business. I have yet to find another gel liner as good as MAC's. First used a friend's and ran straight to the nearest MAC counter to buy it. Lasts forever as well so it's absolutely worth it! The dramatic look it gives you is simply impossible to get with liquid and pencil liners.