This is a really good eyeliner, don't get me wrong, but I'd rather spend a little more on something that lasts longer in heat and also over the course of a day.
The consistency is really smooth, but it just too easily slides and transfers...Oh well!

My favorite eyeliner ever! I bought it with MAC 209 Liner Brush and it is fantastic. Goes on smooth, no pulling, doesn't bother my eyes, and it blends beautifully. It lasts a while, but in Florida's heat and humidity nothing lasts forever. I spritz a q-tip with MUFE Mist & Fix and blot it on my eyeliner when it's really hot outside (almost every day here). The pot of eyeliner lasts forever, and there's no sharpening involved. You really can't go wrong with this product. continued >>

I use this every single day with MAC's 208 Angled Brow brush (OOPS. but it works!!) -- it's fantastic for a thick cat eye, great for a retro look. Also fab for a double-cat eye / Cleopatra look. Stays on all day and doesn't run all over my lids. Love love LOVE it.

finally a liner that stays put on my lower lash line & waterline! this is more gel based than the Mark Keep It Going liner, which is creamier. The keep it going lasts long too. I find the MAC formula a little easier to work with. This dries quickly & lasts all day. I've had it on 10 1/2 hours & it's still going strong. Impressed it didn't smudge or fade off like most liners do on my lower lash line! I've been wanting to try this for a while & I'm glad I finally did. Wish it came with a brush though. Highly recommend this. I've tried the Maybelline Gel Liner & I didn't care for it as much, as it did not stay on my lower lash line. continued >>

This is a really nice gel liner. It's very adaptable - easy to create a thin line with or a thick cat flick with the right brush. However, I love really dark liners, and you don't get the pigment with this that you would with a liquid liner, hence why it is my perfect daytime liner! The formula is really creamy, the first time I bought it it dried out quickly and I swore never to try it again, but I'm glad I did because I think it was a one-off that this happened, as now they usually last me at least 6-12 months before it begins to get really dry. I would definitely buy this product again, as it's so beautifully creamy and super easy to blend!

Great formula! I'm decent at applying gel liners, but I still need a little more practice. This liner lasts all day and doesn't flake off ( I'm looking at you l'oreal hip creme liner ) I probably won't repurchase just because I like pencil or retractable liners better & because this will last me foreverrr. continued >>

i love this product but the only bummer is that its expensive in australia. however, its well worth paying the price for the quality that you do get

This is the perfect product, paired with and angled brush for winged out cat eyes! Application is easy, consistent and creamy and it lasts for a long time ( product size aaand staying power). I like to use this on my waterline sometimes.. Although Im not sure if it's waterline approved! A must have in EVERYONE'S makeup bag / collection!

I absolutely LOVE this eyeliner! It's a little pricey but totally worth it. It is very pigmented and very black. I wear contacts and I can use this in my water line without it bothering me. It glides on so easily and I can do a wing look so easy. I would definitely recommend this and it will last a long time.

Best eyeliner, hands down.
I get compliments allll the time about how nice my eyeliner looks, and I don’t even do anything special! Granted I use an eco tools eyeliner brush for about $4 and this looks perfect all day!
It is cheap compared to other gel eyeliners, and considering how long this has lasted me and how it hasnt even dried out at all, I rather buy one of these eyeliners every 2 years opposed to consistently buying cheap crap from the drugstore.
I have recommended this to EVERYONE, and they all liked it :)