This eye widener doesn't do anything for me! I purchased it in pearl white, and it doesn't show up at all. It has a harsh texture like a real pencil being dragged across my skin. I don't know what I'll do with it, but it was only $1.00. So not a terrible loss.

I got this in Coffee and I *love* it!! Goes on super duper smooth, no tugging at all and dries to a powder like finish. I used to be faithful to MAC's Stubborn Brown Powerpoint, but I dislike the price tag for a basic brown eyeliner. So I thought I give this a try and I dare say that I like it better because it goes on so much smoother. I would love if it had a rubber smudger on the other end, but that's okay.

I tried this product at a friend's house and absolutely hated it. The white was not intense, meaning I had to go over again and again to even get the slightest bit to show up. The liner also is a rough on application. But I guess it's what you get for paying $1, right...?

I was alway curious about e.l.f. and the quality of their products. I found the liner at Big Lots and I decided to try it. I bought this in black.
It creates a thin dark black line, without being hard. It's soft, but not like Khol, and gets real close to the lash line. However, once i curl my lashes, most of the product ends up on my eyelash curler, than on my lids. Which sucks because the color is really nice. I have to curl my lashes before I put this liner on. Disappointing.

I got this in the shade "guilded" which is an antique gold. It is a very nice shade, however you do have to go over the same area a few times to get a good payout. It's more of a brownish gold, but looks fantastic with my green eyes.

I took off a lippie for the fact that the top does NOT fit the pencil at all, and it is kind of hard to apply.

This was the worst line I have ever had. It is sooo hard. you have to press hard on your lids for this to even show. The lid on the liner just falls right off so you could never travel with it. I guess for a buck what did I expect.

I've bought this liner in both Plum and in the White and while it does take a lot of the product to produce color, I do enjoy the end results. I haven't found another Plum color for such a great price yet.

Also, I bought the White liner for a friend of mine who has very small eyes and applied it around the inside corner of the eye and along part of the eye lid. Combining that with some purple shadows and shimmer has a nice widening effect for her.

Between the two liners, more of the White liners have been crumbly for me. The Plum liner hasn't been as extreme.

Will definitely buy this again and it's nice that it does come with an individual sharpener since the pencil wears rather quickly. Or perhaps I'm just brutal with my liners!

This eyeliner isn't very pigmented and tends to smudge. It works alright on the top lid but on the waterline it's pretty pointless as it wears off in minutes. It's only a dollar but that doesn't justify the quality. There are much better drugstore eyeliners for only a few dollars more.

so very disappointed! I like elf e/s, LOVE their lip shine, but the e/l sucks. Hard as graphite. Bummer. I may not even try to swap it; might just write with it, as that's about all it's good for IMO.

This is so horrible! It does not go on smoothly, it tugs and doesn't brighten my eyes up what so ever. I'm glad I only spent $1 on this thing, or I would have been more upset over how bad this product is!