I have had the same bottle of this for YEARS now, and though I should probably throw it away at this point, it still works just fine so I'm holding onto it. This eyeliner is cheap and WORKS. I have bought more expensive eyeliners that worked far less well. The brush is easy to use, and it is wet when first applied, so you can blend it right away/wipe it off if you mess up. It dries fairly quickly though, so don't wait too long. It also is surprisingly long-lasting. It's not waterproof, though, and if you rub your eyes a lot it will definitely come of. Still a great product though, totally recommend this.

Really good eyeliner! Like others have mentioned it is a true black, very pigmented, and very affordable. I have repurchased this over and over again and never been disappointed.

i love this liner, its very black. true black. i hate the brush applicator, i prefer a felt tip. i cant make good "wings" with this brush. i wont buy again for this reason but will try the wet n wild creme liner

I love this! This is an awesome eyeliner. And I love how it has a little brush tip instead of a felt tip. It doesn't smudge at all. It's perfect. And inexpensive. :P

I really wanted to like this liquid eyeliner. First off the color is really pigmented. I was amazed at how much color there was when I swatched it onto my hand. The brush is really flimsy, I wish it was more sturdy and easy to control. When I looked into the mirror after 4/5 hours it had already transferred onto my lid and by the end of the day it all smeared and got onto my lid. Maybe its because of my asian eyelids that makes it easier for it to smudge, I wouldn't buy this again despite how cheap it is.

I thought this product worked very good, give me a good line, and comes in pretty colors. Definitely will purchase again. I recommend this to everyone. Very cheap.

This is probably one of the few cosmetics I'm attached to that I actually have repurchased. I use this in conjunction with my UDPP and it stays put for the most part. After some sweaty clubbing ventures or 7+ hours at work, it starts to smudge a little bit. I have very oily skin and I think that's why it starts to run. It is amazing though, for the price tag and what it does. The brush is easy to maneuver, goes on jet black. I'm content.

Oh my gosh i love this eyeliner. Its so cheap and it works great. It lasts for quite a long time. Its definitely my holy grail :)

This is infact a quite nice liquid liner and is inexpensive. For the first few times I have used it, it is very good but now, when I use it, I don't know why but my eyelid 'stings' when it's applied..
Great black tho, and doesn't smudge

I've gone through literally 10 of these bad boys. Best liquid liner EVER. Sometimes when I wear shimmery shadow it falls out onto my liner and it totally ruins the eyeliner, but not with this stuff! Plus it's so long lasting. I've even had family members ask me how I get my liner to last so long! My only complaint is the brush because after awhile it looses it's shape and hairs stick out...so I wish it was maybe more dense or a velt tip...but def a very good liner.

********edit *********
I have since found better liquid liner, thats longer wearing, but this stuff is still great for the price.