I love this eyeliner. It's long lasting, and goes on smooth without pulling my eye. I hate that tugging feeling and this eliminates that.
i love it i think i do see a definitely in my lashes they fall out less and they do seem fuller, you won't see a dramatic difference if you are looking forward to it everyday, but because im using this eyeliner everyday and not noticing my lashes, when i actually looked at them i saw an improvement. it does not smear does not flake, love the tip and the way it close. can do very fine lines , bought a dark brown and black one, recommend to everybody
i loooove this eyeliner!! the tip is so fine it fills in all gaps of your lashes!
i originally used the dolly wink liquid liner and i loved that one soo much! i think theyre pretty much the same for anyone who was wondering because i was before i tried this one. this one might be a little thinner/watery than dolly wink but it is a lot cheaper tho and can be found pretty much anywhere for around 10-12 dollars. dolly wink is much more expensive (unless you buy on sasa.com = 13$) but usually in japanese stores its lik 20+$. neither of these smudge so if you have oily lids (i'm pretty sure i have oil wells in my lids lol) you're safe! however, they are not waterproof which is fine with me, makes taking off makeup easy, just cottonswab with water. it stays on better than loreal lineur intense and maybelline line stiletto though, in terms of water resistance. if i get teary eyes while using loreal one the liner comes off but this one holds a bit better.
i think this one flakes a bit more than the dolly wink
I really like this liner. I never really used liquid liners much before but I found myself wanting a bolder line. The pen design is definitely way easier than the ink-pot designs out there. I've only started to wear this daily, so I don't know if my lashes are improving or anything, but I'd like to think they would lol. I have this liner in Ultra Black & I'm planning to get brown because brown liner looks more natural on me for everyday wear, while Black is great for when I'm going all out with my makeup. As for the staying power, it doesn't budge once it's dry. However, I have very oily eyelids, so if I want any type of eyeliner to not crease/smudge, I have to wear eyelid primer (I love E.L.F.'s eyelid primers...they're only $1-2!)
Love this. Makes the winged out lines. Color is not super pigmented even the ultra black, but oh well. Last a pretty decent time. I am currently running out of this one. Time to hit Walmart soon!!
I have Asian eyelids that smudges with every eyeliner out there. This is the only that barely smudges (I think the brown smudges more than the black). On my lucky days there will be no smudging. Definitely my go-to eyeliner. Some notes:
-It dries very quickly so you are forced to apply as fast as you can, or else it will tend to get into a goopy mess.
-Not sure about the lash boosting, but I wouldn't recommend it for that purpose since I personally don't really see a difference in my lashes plus I really can't imagine this doing anything for the lashes since it does dry so quickly.
-Extremely easy to remove when washing my face, but stays on throughout the day. This part is super AWESOME. :)
-I got in one in brown and black, I think the brown is pretty dark that it looks like black. If you don't go over it again, it will look like a transparent dark brown, which is pointless too.
-In short, awesome eyeliner for other Asian folks that have the same problems with smudging like me out there. Sometimes CVS/drugstores will have deals on PF products so be on the look out for that and stock up.
I bought this along with the NYX super skinny eye marker. I have to say, while this isn't as pigmented as the NYX one, the brush on this is AMAZING. It makes drawing a nice fluid line very easily and effortlessly. I wish the pigmentation was better but all in all, i would buy this again. Retails for about $10 at Target. Wears pretty well... with minimal smudging. As for the boosting serum, i can't comment since I don't wear this eyeliner every day so it would take a while for me to notice any changes (if any) haha.
Love everything about this eyeliner...but made the mistake of buying "Black" instead of Ultra Black. I still love the precision, the size of the tip applicator and most of all that it feels like in your hands like you are using a pen so its so easy to use. I will be purchasing the darkest black soon!
The brush on this eyeliner is really nice and give a smooth line. It's not very pigmented though, so I find myself going over the line a few times, which can lead to flaking. But unlike other eyeliners I've tried, this is pretty smudge proof, so I don't have to worry about racoon eyes. This is great for a sleek, fine line.
In Ultra Black it is my HG. It is not overly shiny like L'Oreal or the new Shiseido liner (old Shiseido one was my favorite, but not as long lasting). PF is pretty long lasting too. Reminds me a lot of the Shu Uemura pen in terms of formula and finish, but PF has a thinner brush (which I like) and it does not clog. It is free flowing and no fuss unlike most pen liners. Super easy to control, better then K-Palette, as PF is darker and easier to control. I like liner to be super dark, and I find that this in ultra black is very dark. Defiantly darker then Mac Black Track,which I found very dull along with the La Femme cake liner.