It doesn't smudge all day. I have not been able to find an eyeliner that compares. It doesn't irritate my sensitive, contact-wearing eyes. And, it comes off easily with an eye makeup remover.
I have used these eyeliners for years and love them. They hold up well without smudging throughout the day. I've used bronze and prune and love both, but prune is my favorite color. I have purchased this eyeliner more times than I can remember, and I will continue to be a regular customer. 6-11-05 Update: I've been using fumee lately, and love that shade as well. It's a dark gray that for some reason, works very well on my PPP skin. Lancome seems to have come out with a wider color selection lately, so I'll be trying some of those as well in the future I assume.
I have this in Aubergine. Works great and love the color, but it's a little too expensive for me to buy again.
These eyeliners are great and have wonderful staying power. But, with my oily lids, these still don't last all day, but they fare much better than a lot of liners out there.
I have Cafe which rocks! Its a deep brown chocolate shade. Really gives a smooth line.
I have tried two colors so far, Cafe and Noir and I love them. Cafe I have actually repurchased three times.They are waterproof but are easy to remove, without tugging. I don't swim so I do not know how it would hold up in water.But it does not smudge or disappear during the day. This eyeliner is so worth the price(a little over $20). The packaging nice, a swivel up, too bad it is not retractable.