I have a LOT of experience with liquid and gel eyeliners, and This is a great liner one of the greatest. I can get a perfect black-lined cat eye in seconds. It lasts forever,but comes off easily. The black stays true and doesn't fade to grey like someother blacks. I love artliners, but the brush on this is easier to work with and creates a cleaner line. I'll repurchase this for sure, I also want to try the geisha ink (although it's much more expensive and probably a very similar product)
EDIT: I purchased this in Biker, which is supposed to be a dark grey. I even sampled it in the store: it came out grey. I got it home and it's a light silver verging on blue! I like the colour (I wouldn't have purchased it if I knew how it would wear) and I'm hoping maybe after I break it in more it will come out a dark grey. Weird!
The eyeliner of my dreams. I have oily lids and wear eyecream and my entire existence is a fight against panda eyes. All eyeliners smear on me, it's a given. The only ones I've been able to count on are MAC Liquidlast and Kat's other liquid liners. This beats them out because it looks softer than they do (and most other liquid liners) and lasts forever. I can't tell you what a relief it is to look in my rearview mirror at the end of a hot day running errands and see that my eyeliner is still on and in place. It's a miracle.
I should note that trying it on in Sephora didn't impress me; it seemed streaky and skippy and just kind of weak. Luckily it goes on smoothly and looks great. So if you're looking for an eyeliner that lasts forever but you want something less harsh than the typical liquid look, try this. You won't regret it.
I freakin love this eyeliner!!! I'm an eyeliner junkie, always on the look out for easy, quick to use eyeliner that stays put and this one really does the job! I have always been realllly bad at applying liquid eyeliner, either the line is too thick or it looks rigid, but this is effortless, fool proof....seriously! It glides on so easily and stays all day! This price is the only problem, it's a big steep at $18 but I will have to repurchase, I feel like throwing all my other eyeliners away now! I rarely ever say this but this is HG all the way!!!
I purchased this (in Trooper) based on outstanding MUA reviews, and wound up returning it to Sephora - something I very rarely do. I was hoping the MA I talked to at Sephora could tell me what I was doing wrong, but had no luck with that. The product both blobbed and skipped and sort of beaded up on me, and much of it flaked off in no time. Figuring maybe the contents weren't mixed well, I I tried shaking the heck out of the product, wiping the tip lightly before application, making sure my skin was super clean, trying it over a thin wash of primer, going over it with various brushes - just about everything I could think of - but still it beaded up. And it performed even worse on my waterline. It was also fairly shiny, and I prefer a more matte liner.
Bought this because of a YouTube review and since I have really oily eyelids I really need something that will stay and give me great cat eyes.. so I went to sephora and bought it.. tried it the next day and WOW.. is this stuff really pigmented.. and goes on so smooth. The staying power is really great and my wings come out so perfect! Will keep purchasing.. worth all $18.
Great product! Creates any size line you want, easy to apply. Water resistant so it doesn't smudge but it is not water proof. Stays on all day without smudging or smearing. Affordable price. I purchased a different pen liquid eye liner prior to this one that was double the price and I was only half as satisfied with it. Very black colour is great for creating bold eyes or cat eyes.
This is a pretty good product. It has pretty decent staying power with my oily lids. It can stay on my lids for about 4-5 hours without a primer, which is pretty good since I also live in a humid climate. The brush tip makes it easy for application. You can make as thick or thin of a line as you want. This is perfect for those who are new to liquid liners and lazy people like me in the morning. I got this in black, and although the color is not as black as I would like for it to be, the color is buildable.
I bought this after reading all the good reviews, and used the Sephora F&F discount on it. Unfortunately it came out non-opaque and when I tried to retrace the line it just erased what I'd already done. I expected more from a mid/high end product, returned it. Really wanted to love it though, and it's not the absolute worst I've tried. I do love the packaging, both the functionality and the looks :)
This eyeliner is so good! When I put eyeliner I would smudge throughout the day but this one stays long even before I go to bed, the only thing is it's kinda hard to take it off even when your using it with eye makeup remover
bought this in Sk8er- and love it!
very pretty blue color and super easy to use. The only down sides I see is sometimes I have to retrace parts of my line to make sure they're opaque, and as is the case with many other eyeliners, it would be great if the cap fit on the end of the eyeliner so I don't have to trace it down when I'm through lining my eyes!