First time stepping away from UD's eyeliners and I really like his one. I haven't used a felt tip in years and I love the application,how long it lasts, and how black it is. I used the liner tons on mascara and red lips for dinner. I did my eyes early thinking I would have to fix them but this eyeliner was not budging and at dinner I was so hot and this stuff did not move.
When I got home my eyes looked great and they this stuff did not budge,flake, or make me tear. Really a great liner. I would invest in more as I like using the tip and I read how others trim theirs which, is great to know.
I do think Perversion is darker but it's not an issue of which one is darker it's which one suits my needs for the look I'm going for. When I want a sexy eye with not a lot of effort I'm going with my Stila pen without a doubt.
Found my new HG eyeliner. I'm a contact lens wearer and have always had issues with raccoon eyes (I even carry makeup remover and q-tips in my purse for this reason), but this has put a major stop to that. The only thing that shows up under my eyes hours into the day now is slight flecks of mascara (and I'm ok with that until I find a non-flaking mascara). Took off one lippie because unlike a lot of reviewers here, I'm not a fan of the tip. It's too long and too soft for my tastes (I prefer the short, sharp, hard felt tips that Prestige and Almay use for their liquid eyeliners). I fall asleep with this stuff on a lot and wake up with my eyeliner perfectly intact--a miracle considering I used to have to constantly reapply my eyeliner during the day. Kinda pricey but definitely worth it. I'll never stop using this stuff.
Hate this eyeliner, used it for about twice and threw it away.
Don't waste your money on it,especially when it's not cheap at all.
This is my first foray into high-end liquid liner. It's pretty expensive so I used a Collection 2000 one (reviewed on here) until I got the technique right. Once I got the winged eyeliner look down (thank heavens for Youtube!) I treated myself to this Stila pen. I've got to say, I am really impressed. OK, I know that a lot of reviewers on here have said that it flakes, that little hairs start to separate from the "nib" and that it runs out really quickly. And I agree. I noticed that if I used my eyelashes curlers AFTER applying the eyeliner, it would flake off in parts. So I curl my lashes BEFORE applying. And now, on me, it doesn't flake at all. When I go to the gym, afterwards it can fade a little, granted, but nothing that a fresh application can't fix. I have only had 1 hair that I had to snip off with nail scissors, and that was simple enough. And I've been using mine since mid-September (today's date is 2nd November) and it's still going strong. It does *feel* like it's going to run out about a month's worth of use, however, if you shake it vigorously after every stroke and keep the pen at a 45 degree angle (instead of horizontal which is usually what happens when doing a winged eye), you can eke it out longer. This stuff lasts all day as well and once it dries will not smudge. A good dose of baby oil followed swiftly by a good cleanser will remove it. I've already bought a back up of this I like it so much. You can't beat a neatly winged eye teamed with a sexy red lipgloss. Gorgeous.
It was lovely! This was my first higher-end eyeliner, and it visibly delivered when I put it on - the colour was dark and inky, didn't smudge, and it was gratifyingly easy to use. The real problem came at the end of the day - when I was faced with a mirror after returning home, I saw that there were patches of my skin showing through my eyeliner! It had flaked, but I was confident it was the exception rather than the rule, and wore it again the next day, only to have the same problem. I'm quite disappointed, as this seems to be a HG eyeliner for others.
Best liquid liner ever. Love the tip, easy to use!
THIS is one of the best eyeliners. It makes it easy for me to do a decent cat eye, stays all day and looks great. You will like this!
I have been using liquid eyeliner for years and have never been satisfied until I found this product. I have not been disappointed! It is long lasting and has a great brush tip for creating many different looks.
My favorite liner! This liner stays on all day.
This has been my Never-Fail eyeliner for the past 1 year. Everything smears on me, regardless of primer or eyeshadow or waterproof or whatever. I always look like I'm seriously ill because my eyeliner somehow makes its way down to completely cover my lower eyelids. I look like one of those zombies you see in those Halloween movies. (I'd say while most eyeliners completely cover my lower eyelids - 100% grey eyelid, Bobbi Brown gel liner covers only the outer third of my lower eyelids - 33% grey eyelid).
This eyeliner smears a little too, but just where the outer corners of my eyes meet - 10% grey eyelid. This is a HUGE improvement. No zombie eyes. This is the only eyeliner that doesn't fall to my lower eyelid and creating a horrendous purple/grey shadow.
Tip: Don't layer this eyeliner. The more you layer it, the more likely it will flake (it's happened to me). But of all the top-notch liquid eyeliners I've used, this one flaked the least, AND when it did flake - it didn't drop into my contacts. Also, don't try to layer this on top of oily eyelids. Wash your face and make sure your eyelids are free of oils as much as possible. It'll allow the eyeliner to adhere to your skin and buy you an extra few hours of having clean lower eyelids.
P.S. If you find the tip gets kinda floppy and uncontrollable, just cut the floppy bit off with scissors. I find I have to cut the tip (about ~1mm) every couple months in order to draw a straight line.
:Edit: December 7, 2012
I had to downgrade this by 1 star because I finally found my true HG eyeliner (Milani's Eye Tech [the one in the gold short case]).
If you guys really love Stila's All Day eyeliner, you'll like Milani's Eye Tech Extreme [it's regular pen length in a plastic black case]). Extreme is literally an EXACT dupe of Stila's All Day Eyeliner, except cheaper (can be $5 on sale or regularly $8). Same amount of smudginess as well.