not even enough ink to finish my very 1st eyeline at all, and the tip split into two on the 1st (and the last) use. lol

I wish I could give this 0 lippies. Didn't work, was dried up the first time I used it. I like the idea of an eyeliner pen but obviously the packaging was bad enough that it caused the pen to dry up. I wish I could comment on the payoff but it was too dried up to even produce any form of color. Total POS.

not really waterproof, but i like this because its cheap and good colour pay off. i lost mine:(

This pen works amazingly it is not the most pigmented and it is a little to dry but I usually wear this alone without primer or shadow on my lids its lasting power is OK it lasts for about 4 hours before the color starts to flake away. The pen itself it extremly easy to work with I love it so much more than regular liquid eyeliner bottles overall this is an OK product and ii would probably repurchase

Lousy. Dries up even before i get to start on the second eye. Nuff said.

I love this liner. I bought it in both brown and black. The brown one I got at dollar tree got it home and it was dried out I was like wtf super sad face. However i did order the black one with my last ELF haul and it worked perfectly. I think Dollar Tree just got a bad batch. I find it best to order ELF straight from there website as there customer service is super friendly and if your products arent intact they are eager to replace it. Couldn't get any better for $1. Complete thumbs up with a smile.

I loved the way this liner looked in the applicator and I thought it was going to be great. Boy, was I wrong! it seemed like it was already dried out as soon I used it for the first time, 2 seconds after I took it out of the packaging!

Also the felt tip seemed to have been separated so what little bit I did get was detached and looked horrible. I guess I should not have expected so much for a $1

I like to have a thick line when I do my liner and this just doesnt do it for me. Like most other peopler said, it seemed that the pen was really dried out so I couldnt use it straight on. If I did a line at an angle it worked pretty well but I didnt have very good precision doing it that way. I wouldnt really recommend this product because there are other liquid eyeliner pens that are just a little more expensive but are a lot better. I think Im goign to try the gel liner, I usually have better luck with those anyway!

I bought this product in search for a cheap waterproof eyeliner. I bought it in ASH color.
Its hard to apply because the tip is not moist with liquid liner and seems to me a little dried out. Im not sure if all are like that or I bought a defective one.

Its definitely easier to apply it to my right eye but when I do my left, it is much more difficult especially because of the semi dry felt tip. I try to shake the pen so that the liquid gets forced to the the tip but it doesnt seem to make a difference.

It doesnt apply wet which was the only thing I liked. The instant I applied it it was dry, kind matte powdery finish.

I did do a swatch on my hand and held it under running water. Sad to say that it failed to hold up to its waterproof claim.

I do like this product alot.
but it dries out WAY too quickly.
-the price is only $1, so what can you expect ?
-the packaging also sucks, because when you go too put the pen back in the cap, it comes out all weird half the time,
-will not buy again.