I'd like to start off by saying that even if this was only a dollar, I expected a LITTLE better from ELF. Their brushes, for one are ahhh-mazing for the price, and their eyeshadow is good too. Back on track... this eyeliner pen royally SUCKED. Like, really bad. So bad, I must warn you. Maybe I'm just overreacting, but it let me down. The moment I got home from target, I swatched this puppy. It wasn't absolutely amazing but I figured this would be my everyday, easygoing eyeliner while saving my expensive ones for special occasions. The tip softened and broke off by the second use and dried up by the third. The pigmentation sucks! This thing Sucks!! Don't buy it :P
This pen is super easy to use for people with unsteady hands. It does stay on pretty well, like another reviewer said, use a primer. The main problem with it is that it does dry out. I just run it under the sink for a quarter of a second, then wipe the tip's excess water on my hand or tissue, and it's ready to use. This is really awesome for one dolla.
I didn't like this. I expected it to be nicer. It's easy to apply, looks nice at first, but when it dries it looks crackly and smudges easily. I think I have oily eyelids so that might be a factor. I don't like this liner, I don't recommend it. I would recommend their gel liner!
I loved how this product worked! I am light skinned so i needed a very thin line so that I did not look gothic and it worked perfectly for awhile. It dries out eventually but it is worth it!
No joke, it dried out before I even used it. I usually like elf products but I didn't even get to use this one! I tried wetting the tip and storing it with its cap down but that didn't even work.
The first few times I used this eyeliner I thought it was pretty good in terms of the darkness and the formula, though I wasn't a fan of the felt tip because I can't get it to draw fine lines and after a while loses its shape. This pen dried up pretty fast and I had to toss it out. Even though it's only $1 I wouldn't buy again because it dries easily and I would have to replace it often.
Not a fan. Thought I'd give it a shot because I love their self-sharpening pencil liners. This one, not so good. You have to press way too hard to get anything out (not good for an eye product), the liner itself wasn't very pigmented, and the tip seemed unusually sharp to me (again, not good for an eye product). I'm not too bummed because I got it with a bunch of other stuff during a 50% off sale, so I barely paid anything for it. Still, they have other great products which are a better choice for your money than this liner. Pass for me.
This eyeliner is horrible! Nothing would even come out of the tip. After about ten tries trying to get the eyeliner out, the brush eventually became worn out. Never buy this product.
I had zero hopes for this pen but I bought it on a whim because what the hell, it was only $1. the staying power is AMAZING. I swatched it on my hand and it lasted the whole day with a few washes in between. It is also super pigmented and the tip is very fine. I store mine tip side down so it's always ready to go. I honestly have no complaints about this pen. It even beats the chanel pen I used to use, so not worth the money.
Overall, I like this product. the cap is a little hard to get off because it just has such a tight grip? I don't know but my hands always slide off a couple times before I actually get it open. It is not waterproof as it says. But it is very pigmented, the pen applicator works very nicely, you can get whatever sort of line you want with it. Despite the packaging and non-water resistance I would buy this again because it works and it's only $1 so it's worth it. I don't expect magic for $1. I like this a little less now because after a fairly short time the tip started to splay