I am a mascara-holic, and Maybelline is one of my favorite brands. I was reading up on here for reviews and I should have known better by what you lovely people said...length-yes, separation-yes. Volume-no. And it took the curl completely out of my lashes. I even did two coats. I recurled my lashes (Shu Uemera of course) when totally dry, even though I have read multiple times that this might cause lash loss. I liked my lashes better after the curl, but that is true for ANY mascara.
Yeah, I am still not impressed with it. Maybe this is because I need volume! So anyone with need or desire for just length and definition, you might like this.
Just for reference, The Colossal is my HG so far...I have used two tubes. Lash Blast by Cover Girl is good also.
Don't take my word exclusively: TarotLadyLissa, on youtube is another Maybelline mascara devotee, so I suggest you go there and look at her review...she actually likes this mascara.
THIS MASCARA IS AWESOME!LENGTHENS LIKE CRAZY.DOESN'T CLUMP AT ALL.I AM IN LOVE.I RECENTLY BOUGHT THE OCCILLATION MASCARA BY LANCOME AND THIS ONE IS 100 TIMES BETTER.IM GOING BACK TO BLOOMIES TO EXCHANGE THAT MASCARA FOR SOMETHING ELSE.
It's wierd because all the mascaras I do like gets like mediocre ratings. I absolutely love the waterproof Maybelline Lash Stylist but it gets bad reviews. Anyway, this is my new fav mascara. It just applies beautifully to my eyelashes. I been asked twice do I fake lashes on. Like someone else said this is not a voluminizing mascara but it doesn't claim to be. It does lengthen though!. And didn't clump or flake for me. The first time I used it though, the smell was overpowering but I am now on my tenth use of it and the smell has faded which makes me happy.
This was an OK mascara. It made my lashes darker, and a bit longer but I had higher expectations for this. The one good thing about it was that it does not clump.
Really, really like this. My lashes are very thick but stubby so volumizing mascaras tend to be a clumpy disaster for me. This is a fairly thin formula with a long skinny brush that I find seperates my lashes as I put it on, which is great b/c I hate lash combs. If you like lengthening mascaras give this one a try.
The tube reminds me of a Christian Louboutin shoe so thats good. And actually this is a good mascara. I got lots of length and no clumping or smudging at all! This is definitely all about length and not volume but It looks really pretty and glam on my lashes. I would rebuy.
This smelled so bad (very similar to Maybelline's eye makeup remover) that I couldn't stand it. I did like the shape of the brush, but the smell is so bad I'm going to return it tomorrow. I don't recommend this at all.
This was just okay for me. Nothing really to complain about...it didn't smudge, so that's good. It did flake though. There were no dramatic results, nothing special. I'll stick with my 2 favs - Lash Blast and Full & Soft. That is until the next new great thing in mascara comes along....;-)
Ehhh, just another average DS mascara. Nothing "Stiletto" about it, won't repurchase
I bought this mascara based on the name and packaging. Overall, it's just "ok." My "go-to" masacara is still maybelline Great Lash, with curved brush. This mascara covered well and didn't clump, however, I couldn't get over the smell. My boyfriend actually asked me what I had been drinking. He said it smelled like cheap, old beer. Probably wouldn't recommend.