Okkk. So, the first time I used this, I loved it. It gives great volume and expanded my eyelashes greatly. The only downside was it did clump a bit and it was SO hard to get off. Most mascaras are, but this one was honestly the hardest one to get off out of any others that I've tried. (especially the waterproof version of this.) My eyelashes were literally falling out trying to get it to gently come off, even after a shower.
The reason why I only give it 2 stars now is because whatever reason, the past few ones I have bought must be old or defective or something, because they suck! The solution was pretty much dried out, and it just didn't work at all. It was awful.
So now, unfortunately I do not trust this mascara, which is a shame, because it really was very nice the first time. I will never buy this again.
Well, I got suckered in. Looked at this mascara for a long time now before trying it. Man, I am so disappointed. I wanted that false lash look and thought this had to be it. Nope. It's flaky and leaves my lashes very spidery. I HATE that spidery look. It is so tacky IMO. You can literally SEE the mascara on my lashes which I don't think is attractive. And not in the good way where my lashes look huge and possibly false. They look like I tried too hard and didn't know what I was doing.
The brush is traditional and curved, which is not my thing either. The formula is between wet/dry. Two coats and I was picking off the tips of my lashes with my fingers because it balls up. Didn't hold a curl either. I am seriously not impressed with this and wonder why people love it so much, even seeing people on Youtube putting it on with the same spidery effect and loving it? It just looks ridiculous and they love it. Props to you if you can pull that off or put this on without it doing that.
I like it but I'm not gonna buy again. It does its job on making my lashes look longer but it doesn't make much of a difference or atleast look like falsies. It tends to dry really fast and becomes flaky!
Overall, for the price , this mascara is great. A little clumpy and thick but it makes my eyelashes look amazing. The only reason I hesitate to give it a 5 is because nothing will ever top loreal voluminous for me. I will re purchase this again though I am sure, it's quite nice. Brush is nice, it is curved. Thick thick formula.
I got this mascara in waterproof and didn't like it at all. The volume and length it gave was average, and it didn't have the false lashes look at all. The product was also quite heavy and flaky after a couple of hours. And the worst part? Removal. Trying to remove it was hell! It did a damn good job at being waterproof but would not come off fully with any make up remover or vaseline, and lots of eyelashes fell out in the process.
I definitely expected more from this mascara. Wont be buying again.
I am a HUGE mascara fan - love to highlight my eyes with thick, dark lashes. I purchased this mascara during the summer and hated it, it was flaky, almost melty in the heat, and clumped like crazy. Now it's winter and I love it - though I still notice flakes after application and definitely some clumping, which is annoying to deal with. However, if you're looking to have major thick, fanning lashes, this mascara will do it.
I love love love this mascara but i wish it was waterproof. Good mascara esp for the price
I loved this mascara. It lives up to its name. Favorite part about it is that I don't have to curl my lashes with this mascara.
Favourite mascara of all time, maybeline has really got it spot on here. Such an excellent mascara👌
I liked this mascara quite a bit, other than the fact that after a month or so it got really flakey and 2 coats made each eyelash look like a big clump.