Bought this as my very first mascara! The first thing I noticed was the musky, floral scent which was quite unpleasant. The packaging is cute, but I'm not a huge fan of the mascara itself. It does add some length but it's rather clumpy and some bits actually get into my eye. Wouldn't repurchase!

I absolutely love this mascara! I've tried so many mascaras and none can compare to the length this mascara gives me. I am asian and just uploaded two pics of my results, the one where you can see my face and my eyes are closed and the other one is my full face looking at the camera. I can build the effect from natural to waaay dramatic and it also grabs every lower lash whereas other mascara just can't do the same thing! I do however, put a coat of L'oreal Black Carbon Voluminous on the edges for a cat eye effect. This mascara is perfect for LENGTH and seperation. If you are looking for volume and length, I suggest using this for the length and a volumizing mascara after. It's worth it to me because I get beautiful lashes every time! :-D

I buy the waterproof lash stiletto and have for maybe a year now?? I like this mascara. My lashes are not that long but this mascara really makes them look longer and thicker. I buy a new one every month (im not sure how often you are supposed to replace mascara but i find it doesnt work as good after a month). I agree with previous posts that I've found on here stating that it does not stay on that long. I find my lashes dont look as good after just a few hours which is a bummer but i just re-apply if i notice. I think I will search for a better mascara that lasts longer but this is good for a casual look if you want longer looking lashes, but its nothing drastic.

Tried this some years ago but have moved on since. It's not bad but it didn't do a lot to emphasize my lashes.

I bought this as my first nascara it was okay. it made my lashes look and thick the only thing i don't like about it was the brush its very spikey and it hurts to apply it to the roots and this mascara brush also tends to pull lashes every application because of the spikes. the spike its great for separating and and defining lashes but its too painful just to apply it to the roots because its hard i dosent feel soft when u try to apply it to the roots.

So I made a review for this before but I decided to change it because i thought I'd try this product again. I still hate it. It makes my eyes all watery when I put it on? It also makes my lashes look clumpy :(

I honestly don't understand why so many people have been disliking this mascara. I actually loved it! It gives incredible length and the brush gives you ultimate control. This is actually one of the best mascaras I have ever bought!

I was always intrigued about the packaging and heard great things about it so i went and i got it because i was out of mascara. I really happy about this product because i gives me longer lashes and coats them evenly and they give a nice curl when you use a eyelash curler. This isn't the best mascara that i have ever used but i would buy it again.

I have always loved the packaging of this mascara and for years told myself I would try it. I'm usually not a fan of Maybelline mascaras, they've always been pretty average to me, yet this one's the best I've ever used by them. It really lengthens the lashes and opens the eyes and I absolutely love the wand. I don't even curl my lashes when I use this because it gives a really natural, lengthened look which I like. One of the best things about this is that it's super easy to remove. Once it's off it's off; no morning-after raccoon eyes or unexpected smudging. This is a great mascara and one of my favourites.

Almost ZERO volume, but definitely does give you a more defined look. Does a fair amount of lengthening, and is not clumpy. Gives you a natural fluttery look. Great for younger girls just starting out.

Biggest CON: Idk if it's just me or not, but every time I washed this mascara off, it look weird black filmy bits in my eyes that were rather irritating... as if the face-washing made the mascara go INTO my eye instead of washing off into the sink... contact-wearers and other sensitive-eyed users, BEWARE.