i like this product, it worked for me! it gave me volume and length, it is easy to apply and i like the dark color. it does get flaky, but this is my favorite DS mascara.

I hate this product. After curling my lashes, I like to apply two coats of mascara. This mascara does not come out of the tube cleanly -- the brush has gobs of product between the bristles, and drops the curl of my lashes completely. It also smudges slightly if touched. I will not be repurchasing.

Absolutely LOVE this mascara and I am picky!! One day I forgot to apply to one eye and went out to the mall and to (gasp) Sephora and the SA there asked me what mascara I had on as the difference between the lashes with and without mascara was so striking. This stuff is BEAUTIFUL! I myself discovered it by asking a friend what she had on her lashes to make them so fantastic...I buy in brownish/black for day, and blackest black for evening. Magnifique!

PS. Months later still LOVE this...my favorite mascara from the drugstore or possibly EVER!!

sure, you need to wipe the wand before use and carefully apply two coats. but...the flirty fat lashes is worth the time! and the formula doesn't flake or look flat like other drugstore mascaras(lashblast). i don't thinking it deserves such a bad rap.

A very average mascara in my opinion. It has a nice, full brush. I like the way it volumizes my lashes but it doesn't hold a curl for long. It wears off with time. It is easy to wash off and it's inexpensive. It's not my HG mascara, but it's not the worst I've tried. It needs more umpf!

In my quest for inexpensive beauty products, I've tried my fair share of mascaras that leave clumps, have no effects whatsoever, and are hell to remove.

I came across this product while trawling through the bargain bins at Priceline. In need of a mascara that actually worked (plus it was only $7), I bought it. And I'm glad I did.

While it might not quite live up to advertising standards, it certainly lengthens my lashes, and hardly clumps. And, with a decent eye make up remover, it comes off pretty easily.

What prevented me from giving it top marks is the fact that it's not perfect. It does occasionally clump, and even after I wipe the wand liberally, a little too much product coats my lashes to be considered neat.

All in all, I am satisfied with this product, and will continue using it. I recommend it to anyone who's lashes need a pick me up

Voluminous is much better. This doesnt give much volume or length, you need to work with it a lottt. It clumps and flakes. I got the double package at Target unfortunatley. I will use them up, its not "horrible" but I would never repurchase and am not looking forward to having to use the other one for another few months!

I love this product! If you have naturally long lashes like I do then this will take them to the next level giving you a nearly false eyelash look! ;') This does't smudge or smear and will wear on well into the next day. You definately need a good remover or you will never get it off. Also, one good coat is all you really need. More than that will naturally cause it to cake because that is the nature of the product. I bought mine 2 for 1 and couldn't be happier.

This flakes very badly, I loved this when i first used it. then then the product fell off of my lashes! Save your money!!
UPDATE- just threw mine away, I tried it with primer and in an hour it was still gone.

My lashes are curled and long.I like voluminous mascara.This product stick my lashes together not voluminous.Voluminous mascara(carbon black) is better than this. Package quality is good but it's not deserved this price any more.