It seems that Bad Gal is a "love it or hate it" kind of product for 99% of the MUAers. I'm the 1%, it's not a bad mascara, but what's the big deal? The wand is very unwieldy, I felt like a toddler trying to put on Mommy's mascara with it. The mascara itself isn't bad, it doesn't flake on me and holds a curl. Plus, I like the fact that I can go very dramatic or natural with it. But, is it worth the price? Meh.

I tried this product because I had heard so much about it in magazines and from beauty experts. It didn't do a thing for me! I thought the brush was way too big and the mascara itself did nothing to improve my lashes. I think its way overrated.

Loving this!
Gives me gorgeous lashes, doesn't clump or flake. Just a really perfect mascara.

The big brush is a plus.

EDIT:
Okay so I gave this product another try and I love it. I'm always getting asked what mascara I use. It gives me great volume and length. The odd time I find it flakes but barely. I find it so weird no one really likes this mascara on here.

Not as black as I'd like it to be, but it did lengthen my lashes alot. It holds the curl, which I love. It never ever clumped on me. It just didn't give me the volume I wanted (I was expecting dramatic, fake looking lashes) It was very light and you can definately layer it. It's a good lengthning/seperating mascara. I'm still in search for the perfect mascara, but this came close to it.

MOST OVERRATED MASCARA EVER!!!!! Don't waste your money. I much prefer CLinique's High Impact in black to this. I keep trying to see if I'm missing something because so many people like it, but it does nothing to my lashes. No length (and I expected to look like a hooker with all the hype), no volume, and overall no Ooomph, ya know? I coulda kept my $19. Won't ever buy again.

This is a mediocre mascara and not worth the price. I find cheaper brands like Max Factor and Maybelline are a lot better. I found it clumps too easily. I like that the brush is very big, but that's about it. I wouldn't recommend this to anyone.

gives me the BIGGEST eye lashes and volume. PERFECT

It feels really good going on, but by the end of the day, it ended up all over the bottom of my eye. Nay, at the end of an hour. Maybe I'll try it again when I'm wearing primer, but overall, I wasn't all that impressed. I get a lot more volume (albiet, clumps) from Bourjois Volume Clubbing.

This is just another mascara to me. It looks really nice on, but it flaked. If it hadn't been for the flaking, I would say it's at least a 4 maybe 5.
I am going to try it again tomorrow and see what I think. I may be putting it up for swap (I used and will use a clean brush). I'll come back and edit if it changes my mind.