I've been happy with my Almay oil-free makeup remover, but with this product, you get a lot more for only an extra buck, so I figured it would be a better bargain. Not for me. For a supposedly "oil-free" makeup remover, it leaves a very greasy residue all over my eye area, which is still there even after washing my face. And it doesn't even remove my mascara - which *isn't* waterproof! Even after using this product, after I wash my face I end up with dark circles under my eyes, from the mascara smearing. My Almay makeup remover was non-greasy and did the job, so I will go back to that product instead.
This is really excellent. It takes off all my stubborn waterproof eye makeup and mascara SO easily. I was about to replace my Lancome Bi-Facil but decided to try this first. I'm so glad I did because it is just as good as the Lancome for half the price!
This is actually called "Oil Free EYE Makeup Remover." Yuck! I had to use so much to remove my non-waterproof mascara. Because of this, I got a very greasy residue, which I felt may contribute to getting milia. I will not use this again and am going back to my Maybelline Expert Eyes 100% Oil-Free Remover, which is gentle, effective, and doesn't leave a residue. Although, it won't remove waterproof eye m/u, for those that use it (I don't).
I have been looking for this everywhere! It's been sold out at all the places I've been... and then I saw two left at Target and quicky put both in my basket. I'm so happy I did because this stuff rocks! Seriously, this is just as good as Lancome's Bificils. This is a dual phase makeup remover, so it removes the most stubborn eye makeup. I got mine for around $4 USD each. This is extremely gentle and effective. I have tried Almay's version, but that stung my eyes so badly. I will repurchase this until the day I die or until they discontinue this (which ever one comes first)!
I recently switch to waterproof mascara and therefore needed a more substantial eye makeup remover. First, I used Clinique "Take off the Day" a bi-phase remover that worked very well, but at $15.00 a bottle it was not cheap. At the drugstore, I noticed the new Neutrogena remover ($4.99) and decided to give it a try. I was pleased to find it works just as well as the Clinique product for 1/3 of the cost. As other reviewers have mentioned, it does leave some residue, but that is easily removed by rinsing with a little water. I will definitely repurchase.
This stuff is great. It removes everything without "scrubbing". It doesn't burn or leave you feeling yucky. It reminds me Mary Kay's eye makeup remover but cheaper.
Best makeup remover i've ever used and it's really cheap!
This is a really nice drugstore eye makeup remover. I usually have a problem with drugstore eye makeup removers being too oily and leaving that greasy feeling behind (which is a problem for me since I wear contacts) but this one didn't do that. Very gentle on my eyes. No stinging and no residue. Comparable to more expensive brands but much cheaper.
this is works well, esp tough on waterproof mascaras. just soak a cotton ball and let sit on eyes for 10 seconds and gentyl wipe away mascara. this got my lashes squeaky clean without tugging and rubbing. it does leave a light greasy feeling, BUT a wet tissue will wipe it away asap. i like this better than physicians formula and loreal. scentless and alot qty for the price. ill buy again.
Felt like it had a residual on my face, didn't remove all of my NON waterproof eye make up (altho it claims it will even remove waterproof mascara) but it kinda made my skin felt alittle bit smoother (maybe it's juss the residual???) Wouldn't buy it again tho...didn't do what it promised