I purchased this blush a few weeks ago and am really happy with it. It is a warm nude pink that gives a subtle flush on the cheeks. It is matte with no shimmer so it looks very natural. I haven't had to touch up during the day so the formula seems to be fairly long wearing. For reference I am NC15 and don't have any trouble with it not showing up on my skin like another reviewer but it is subtle so if you want a large pop of color you probably need to layer it with a powder blush or bronzer. So far I am happy with this purchase and will repurchase.

This has been my go-to blush for work every morning for the past 2 weeks. I love the way it gives my skin a soft warmth. I use a flat foundation brush to apply it. I use it on top of tinted moisterizer which gives me a goregous dewy look. I'm more of a fan of the creme rather than the powders. I feel it makes you look more natural and healthy! But, keep in mind I'm NW20. This wont show up on a lot of skintones. When I got it at Sephora, it had obviously been returned with someone's fat fingerprint on it (grrrrrrr!!). Didn't work out for them, but works for me :)
EDIT: This cream blush breaks me out bad. A good dupe is Hush by MAC. -2 lippies for clogging my pores.

I tried Penny Lane because I really wanted to try a cream blush. Unfortunately, it did not even show up on my face. I returned it, and have not tried other creme colors. For reference, I am NC30 and my other fave blushes are Clinique Aglow, LM Crushed Hazlenut, and NARS Zen.

For me, this did not work and I am a blush freak! I love blush and I love cream blush. I am a stila cc junkie. I was excited to try this but the color & texture let me down. Let me first say that I have freckles and for some reason my freckles threw this off, also, I feel it to be more of a muted rose than nude as it was described on the boards. If your looking for a nice peach pink subtle nude cream blush- try stila gerbera. texture..I was disapointed that this turned to a powder when applied. I guess I was hoping it would be more dewey. so anyways, after lemming this for quite sometime I was let down which never happens. most of my reviews are always positive as I normally easily pleased. anyways I guess this was a miss for me. continued >>

Penny Lane is a nice no-makeup kind of makeup. On my NC 20-25 skin it is a subtle nude peachy pink with a beautiful silver sheen( no visible shimmer). It's an effectless dewy, natural looking blush, which is absolutely mistake proof. Won't accentuate pores or acne scars. Amazing texture too, silky, soft and smooth, very easy to blend and built up.

The downsides : (1) too light for me in summer , (2) the lasting power could be better especially compared to other Nars blushes.

This is my HG blush. It's a gorgeous peachy pink shade. It looks very natural and blends easily. It also has a slight glow to it. It looks matte in the pan, and it's not iridiscent or anything on, but the result is this "glowing from within" effect. I will repurchase again, and again, and again!

Amaaazing color!! if your looking for something natural.. this is the one to try! i love it!! i cant imagine such color exists! i have so many other blushes.. this is by all means one of my fav ones.. pure angelic.. and i love the fact that its a cream blush.. i am in love with those since ive tried cream blushes i have lost my desire to use powder ones.

This is a blush that often goes neglected in my collection, but I always remember how much I like it when I "rediscover" it from time to time :) It's a soft, very slightly warm peachy pink/nude shade with very subtle shimmer, almost just an imperceptible glow. As someone who's super pale (NC/W10), it's great to have a blush that is almost literally impossible to overdo, and Penny Lane is one of those shades. I can load it on if I want a sweet-cheeked, yet still natural (really!) look. I use my MAC 188 brush for a perfect application. My only gripe is the lasting power, I feel like this one doesn't last all day and needs a touch up after 4 hours or so. Overall, it's really pretty, and a great addition to anyone's blush collection.

this is a beautiful blush. Its incredibly easy to apply and gives a fantastic natural flush to my cheeks. I would definately buy this again.

I love how this creamy blush actually stays on, is very natural, and the color is very flattering. It's a soft nude and pink color blush. The creamy texture is smooth and not cakey. It glides on and you control the level of intensity - easy to use. The color is so natural and dewy. Would buy again.