I like this product but its not a HG eyeliner for me. Clinique's cream eye shapers are pencil liners that are super creamy and glide on smoothly with no tugging and come in some beautiful shimmery shades. Brown Sugar is the lighter brown. Chocolate Lustre is the dark chocolate brown with shimmer while Brown Sugar is a medium brown infused with gold and shimmer. I think for a pencil liner, this has the best staying power. It definately smudged after 4 hours and did slightly fade as well after 7 hours and a workout. it just smudged slightly though which is really good IMO for a pencil liner. The BB gel liners and Mac fluidlines are still my HG liners but these pencils are a good option when you are in a hurry. I noticed the less eye cream I wear, the better this lasts as well as the better the shadow base, the less the color will fade. I do tend to have really oily eye area so that affects my review. i probably wouldnt repurchase but i do like the softness of this liner. I think they are better than the MAC powerpoints too! Retails for $13.
Nearly identical to MAC teddy eye kohl.