After seeing all the reviews here, I feel kinda compelled to write a review as well. Now I don't mean to be that one debbie downer post but honestly there are better liners out there than this one. I'm talking about the Black shade (not any of the others). .comi.com don't have particularly oily lids, and though I'm in atlanta the humidity isn't the -worst- it could be. However this liner smudges within an hour. The sharpener attached at the end also breaks the liner stick off in pieces rather than sharpen it. This liner is neater and lasts longer if you line it out with one of those spongey stiff smudging brushes and then set with black eyeshadow powder. But bottomline, save your 7-8$ and go buy a milani liquifeye eyeliner. Those things are unbelievably soft and pigmented and longlasting. Or the physicians formula shimmer strips eyeliner trios... those are crazy smudgeproof.
If you're looking for a long wearing, convenient product, this is definitely it. I had the black and it was black. Stays on for a long long time. Pencil is the twist-type with a fine lead so no sharpening required. Sleek black packaging looks good in the powder room. Price is super affordable. Great alternative to liquids and gels. Not good for smudging.
A lot of the reviews I've read on this eyeliner says that it has long lasting power and won't budge at all. I found it to be otherwise. After I applied it, it would start to melt off within an hour. A big disappointment for me. Otherwise, the packaging was good.
I saw that this had a lot of good reviews so I was happy to go out and try this. That's where my love of this product ends. I hate it, it smuged up to my browbone when I tried to set it and when I didn't it went up to my eyebrow and everywhere inbetween. I have much better luck from a $2 pencil than the $22 this costs in Australia.
I know the eyeliner applicator may be hit or miss, but for me, it's definitely a hit. I can control the brush easily therefore making precise lines, whether thin or thick! I definitely would not recommend this eyeliner to eyeliner newbies.
The colour is dark and stays on all day. But if you rub it, it will smudge or come off so obviously, avoid doing this. I've gotten into the habit of not touching my eyes throughout the day so NONE of my make-up smudges.
I think the eyeliner completely lives up to the nice price, as it isn't too expensive but works really well.
I'd buy it again!
Great automatic liner. Highly pigmented, waxy, not too transferring. Probably need to blend a bit into the lash line as otherwise can glide on slightly bumpy.
pretty great product. it is reliable and stays on your lids. however, sometimes the stick breaks and it becomes useless :(. price is good.
I had been looking for the perfect eyeliner for years, onea that was creamy, retractible, with sharpener, not too thick, that worked well on the waterline and on my lids and thatt didn't smudge...finally found it!
I wasn't sure about buying this, but after discovering my boss who always had her eyes so perfectly lined and another girl at my job, i decided to buy it.
It is the best eyeliner I've ever had, it fulfills all my expectations...i can use this in my waterline and lines very well, also on my lids,and it stays forever, until i take off my makeup.
It doesn't smudges at all, unless yo smudge itt when you apply it. I use this everyday and also for nights out, and i never look like a raccoon or a panda.
I tried before the urban decay's 24/7, lancome, l.a. colors, maybelline, covergirl, mac, and nothing works as nice as this....i suuuuper recommend this!!!
Wow, they re-formulated this! I've always loved Colorstay Eyeliners because they're the only liners that don't raccoon on me (*ahem* Urban Decay and MUFE liners). These used be a lot drier and harder to apply though. Now, they're great! Really glide on smoothly.
I will say that it does melt a bit on my lids after half a day but in a smoky way. I don't mind it because it doesn't get on my undereye area - woo!
This is a pretty good eyeliner. I didn't give it a perfect rating because it does melt a little over the course of the day. I do like that it is very pigmented (I have it in black). It is also very creamy and easy to apply, and I like the twist up style. Overall, it performs well and I would recommend it.