this is my HG kohl for any major events .this is soooo long lasting unlike any eyeliners i have tried before..definitely worth the 5 stars!

I wanted to love this product based on the rave reviews, but as soon as I put it on my eyes reacted horribly. They were dry, red, glossy, and just overall awful. I don't know why I reacted so bad to this eyeliner, but from just one use yesterday my eyes are still red and itchy today. I will not be using this again.
On the upside, I did enjoy the pigment and application, I just wish my eyes could handle it.

haha this is my first eye liner in my entire life. and im still absolutely loving this so much! well if youre not wearing any base on your eye, yes it smudges a bit much. but, normally, it stays on me like 4 hours without smudging and the color is very pigmented! the best thing is that you can very easily control the eyeliner. great packaging, worth the price, and the result is gooorrgeous:)

Its not wonder this as so many good reviews it really is the best eyeliner ive used and i get awfully smudgy eyes so much so that i have to wear waterproof mascara daily most eyeliners ive used in the past would end up smudging and giving me panda eyes and then wearing off during the day so there was only a little bit left but this is really good ive fallen asleep in it been in the shower with it and its lasted really well it defo does stay put take it from me this one is defo the best!

If this was sold in regular pencil form I would repurchase. These twisty eyeliners are so gimmicky, they never get pointed enough and are flat again before finishing one eye. This however, does have staying power, it doesn't budge. it works great on lids. On my waterline, it transfers and irritates my eyes making them red and watery.

I lOve it! i look korean because of this lol

This is my HG pencil liner of all time; I've repurchased this twice already, and I already regretted trying a new one instead of this. I love the fact that one end was a convenient little sharpener, and that it was soso easy to draw with. It glided on my lids so smoothly without having to be warmed up or anything and stayed on for most of the day.
A couple of downsides I would mention is how it smudged for me as the day progressed (but I think that's because of my oily lids), and how difficult it was for more to remove all of the product from my eyes. The shade I usually buy is black brown, since it's a natural shade without committing to the intensity of black. Overall, I would 100% recommend this to anyone; I love Revlon's eyeliners.

Awesome pencil eyeliner. It's my favorite. I've repurchased this again and again. Unlike other pencil liners this one doesn't smear. I can wear it all day and it doesn't flake or give me racoons eyes.

This is my HG eyeliner. I rarely repurchase makeup items, but I have bought this eyeliner time and time again. Applies very easily, nicely pigmented, and it *stays*. It doesn't smudge, and even seems to be waterproof- it has never, ever run, even through tears and watery eyes, and yet isn't a hassle to remove at night. My favorite shades are blackberry and cocoa, and I wear both everyday. Both have the *tiniest* bit of shimmer to them, but nothing one would ever really notice (I personally don't like sparkly eye makeup); it's just enough to ensure it leaves your eyes looking bright, rather than flat.
I go through these relatively quickly; with daily application, one will last about a month, month and a half. But even though I'm super cheap and hate throwing down around seven bucks a piece, this product is totally worth it. Only caveat(!): don't untwist them too far- like other people have indicated, it may just fall off, so try to untwist only a bit at a time. Even still, I don't know what I would do if these were ever discontinued (knock on wood!), because they are an absolute staple. Definitely give them a try.

This is a great liner. Stays on all day just like it claims. Can be smudged for a smokey look. Used it for many years and love it! I've never had a problem with it breaking or coming out of the tube like some other reviews say.